135 7 Отзыв Александр 008 (Военкомат проигнорировал 2 моих непризывных диагноза!)

Introduction and Context

Initial Greetings and Mood Check

• The conversation begins with a greeting between the speaker and Alexander, who shares that he is doing well and has started working.

• The speaker expresses gratitude for Alexander's patience and introduces the main topic: discussing his experience in obtaining a military ticket.

Purpose of Discussion

• The speaker emphasizes the value of Alexander's experience, noting it could help others understand nuances related to their situations or avoid mistakes made during the process.

Changes in Mood Post-Military Ticket

Emotional Impact of Receiving Military Ticket

• Alexander reflects on how receiving the military ticket positively changed his mood, alleviating a long-standing burden associated with military obligations.

• He describes this obligation as a weight carried since school days, highlighting concerns about potentially losing a year to military service.

Background on Military Obligation Journey

Overview of Initial Steps Taken

• The speaker recalls when Alexander first reached out regarding his situation while finishing college, mentioning an initial summons to the military commission.

• Alexander explains that all students received summonses for medical examinations at local recruitment offices.

Delays and Legal Consultation

• He notes that many peers received orders for deployment shortly after graduation but faced delays due to personal medical documentation issues.

• Parents decided to consult with a legal firm (Ayur), despite Alexander's skepticism about their effectiveness against recruitment office decisions.

Legal Process and Medical Examination

Initial Skepticism Towards Legal Help

• Despite initial doubts about whether legal intervention would be effective against recruitment office decisions, they proceeded with consultations.

Medical Findings Leading to Further Actions

• After consultations, they focused on confirming Alexander’s heart condition through various medical examinations.

• During one examination session, he was deemed fit for service but contested this decision based on his health condition.

Ongoing Challenges with Recruitment Office

Continued Struggles Against Recruitment Decisions

• Following unsuccessful attempts at court proceedings against the recruitment office regarding his fitness status, they sought independent expert evaluations.

Expert Evaluation Outcomes

• An independent evaluation concluded he was fit for service despite having a heart defect; this led to further complications in communication with the recruitment office.

Year-long Wait and Documentation Preparation

Prolonged Waiting Period Without Communication

• A significant delay occurred where no summons were issued due to administrative changes within regional offices leading to confusion over his case status.

Document Preparation Amidst Uncertainty

• Throughout this period, Alexander continued gathering documents related to another potential diagnosis while awaiting clarity from the recruitment office.

Military Draft Experience and Medical Examination Process

Initial Steps in the Draft Process

• The speaker discusses their experience with the military draft, mentioning that they initially felt forgotten during the call-up period. They decided to take action by visiting the military enlistment office themselves.

• Upon arrival at the KMO (military enlistment office), they were quickly referred to a psychiatrist, where they shared their medical history and received a preliminary classification of B4.

Medical Examination Journey

• After seeing various doctors, including a therapist who took an interest in their case, the speaker was directed for further medical testing due to existing heart conditions.

• They underwent additional examinations which revealed hypertension and other heart-related issues, leading to two non-draftable diagnoses being established.

Challenges Faced During Evaluation

• Despite having documented health issues, the military office ignored these diagnoses during evaluations. The speaker highlights how one condition was confirmed while another was not due to circumstances on examination day.

• Ultimately, after presenting all findings from tests back at KMO, members of the draft commission acknowledged their heart condition and assigned them category V.

Reflections on Strategy and Communication

• The speaker reflects on their approach during this process, noting that they did not fully disclose all health issues initially—a decision they later considered a mistake.

• They emphasize that it is crucial to communicate all health concerns thoroughly as different doctors may focus on varying aspects of one's medical history.

Emotional Struggles and Support Systems

• The discussion shifts towards emotional challenges faced throughout this journey. The speaker recounts feelings of apathy when losing an independent examination or court case regarding their health status.

• A pivotal moment of despair occurred when they lost an independent expert evaluation; however, despite setbacks, hope remained for future appeals.

Importance of Perseverance

• Support from family played a significant role in maintaining motivation through difficult times. Following legal advice helped them stay focused on tasks despite feelings of discouragement.

• The conversation concludes with reflections on resilience—stressing that even when facing adversity or feeling hopeless, following guidance can lead to eventual success.

Advice for Young Men Navigating Military Service

Recommendations for Starting the Journey

• The speaker emphasizes the importance of remaining calm when interacting with military recruitment offices, as emotional responses can hinder progress.

• It is advised to thoroughly understand one's medical condition, including researching it online and consulting with healthcare professionals for accurate information.

• A personal anecdote highlights that minor details in medical conditions (like regurgitation in heart issues) can significantly impact decisions made by military officials.

Importance of Medical Documentation

• The speaker notes that having detailed medical documentation can influence outcomes during evaluations, as seen in their own experience where specific conditions were highlighted during assessments.

• Attention to detail in medical records was crucial; the presence of a noted condition led to further examinations and ultimately influenced the decision regarding fitness for service.

Seeking Professional Guidance

• When seeking advice from peers about military service, it's recommended first to undergo personal medical evaluations before consulting legal experts or advisors.

• Understanding one’s health status is essential before engaging with recruitment processes; this helps individuals make informed decisions about pursuing exemptions or deferments.

Weighing Options: Service vs. Exemption

• The discussion reflects on whether it would have been easier to serve a year versus navigating the complex process of obtaining an exemption due to health issues.

• The speaker acknowledges that while serving might seem simpler, potential health risks associated with military service could lead to more significant problems down the line.

Reflection on Personal Experience

• The individual shares mixed feelings about their journey—while it was challenging and lengthy, they feel satisfaction in having pursued their rights rather than simply serving without question.

• They express that attempting to navigate the system provided peace of mind, knowing they did everything possible regarding their situation.

Conclusion: Individual Paths and Legal Support

• Each person's experience varies greatly; some may find success easily while others face significant hurdles based on their unique circumstances.

• There is recognition that legal support serves as a safety net throughout this process, helping individuals manage uncertainties related to military obligations.

Legal Guidance and Personal Experiences in Military Draft Situations

The Role of Legal Advisors

• Legal advisors serve as a safety net, providing guidance to ensure individuals navigate complex situations correctly. Their support helps maintain confidence during challenging times.

Importance of Timely Actions

• A single timely action can significantly alter outcomes in legal matters. In this case, attention to specific details led to a favorable resolution regarding military obligations.

Consequences of Oversights

• Failing to act promptly can lead to severe consequences, such as being labeled a draft evader. This could result in immediate conscription or detention by authorities.

Acknowledgment of Support

• Expressing gratitude towards the legal team and medical professionals involved is essential. Their efforts often go unrecognized but are crucial for successful outcomes.

Emotional Aspects of Legal Processes

• Lawyers must sometimes adopt a psychological approach, offering emotional support alongside legal advice. This dual role can help clients remain resilient through stressful situations.

Closing Remarks and Future Considerations

• The speaker expresses relief at resolving their issue and encourages ongoing communication for future inquiries related to military service. Sharing personal experiences may help others facing similar challenges.

Reflection on Unexpected Outcomes

• Despite initial setbacks, small details can lead to success in seemingly lost cases. The importance of perseverance and attention to nuances is highlighted as key factors in achieving positive results.