Lo que NADIE te cuenta de ANAXÁGORAS DE CLAZOMENE 😱 (Cuidado con este ERROR) | Presocráticos

Understanding Anaxagoras: Misconceptions and Insights

Introduction to Anaxagoras

• Anaxagoras of Clazomenae is often regarded as the second pluralist after Empedocles, proposing multiple elements (arjés) to explain reality.

• Following Parmenides, who established a singular origin, Anaxagoras argues that multiplicity must arise from the multiple rather than the one.

Key Philosophical Principles

• He accepts Parmenides' view that what exists is uncreated, imperishable, and qualitatively immutable; thus, birth and death are illusions.

• The initial state described by Anaxagoras was a mixture where "all things were together," challenging traditional interpretations of his philosophy.

Homeomerías vs. Semillas

• A common misconception is that Anaxagoras referred to "homeomerías" (homogeneous parts), a term first used by Aristotle rather than found in Anaxagorean fragments.

• Aristotle's interpretation suggests that these homeomerías are composed of parts sharing the same name as the whole (e.g., hair made of hair).

Clarifying Terminology

• The term "espérmata" (seeds), which some attribute to Anaxagoras for describing particles, appears infrequently and does not align with its intended meaning in this context.

• Instead of focusing on specific particles or seeds, Anaxagoras emphasizes "créma" (things), indicating an ambiguity about elemental components.

Nature of Reality According to Anaxagoras

• His primary concern lies not in identifying ingredients but in explaining how diverse realities emerge from an original mixture.

• The second problem with classical interpretations involves misunderstanding his concept of ultimate particles; he believed division continues indefinitely without reaching a minimum unit.

Continuity and Interconnectedness

• Anaxagoras posits that things cannot exist separately; there’s both vertical continuity within divisions and horizontal continuity among all entities.

Anaxagoras and the Role of Noûs

The Concept of Noûs

• Anaxagoras introduces the concept of Noûs, which is described as the only thing that exists separately from everything else. It is essential for understanding the cosmos.

• Noûs is characterized as simple, eternal, pure, and autonomous. It initiates movement in all things but retains some corporeal characteristics.

• This cosmic intellect causes a shift in the original mixture, leading to a separation of elements while maintaining an underlying unity among them.

The Nature of Existence

• Everything contains a part of everything else; however, their proportions vary. For example, if something has more wood than gold, it will be perceived as wood.

• Visible things are merely reflections or combinations of unseen elements. The dominance of one element can mislead us into thinking it is separate from others.

Illusion of Individuality

• Anaxagoras argues that individuality is an illusion; true existence reflects an essential communion within the cosmos where nothing exists independently except for intellect.

Innovations in Cosmogony

• Anaxagoras uniquely assigns a significant role to intellect (Noûs), contrasting with earlier thinkers who attributed creation to necessity or mechanical processes.

• Unlike Empedocles' cyclical view of cosmogony, Anaxagoras posits that intellect organizes the cosmos once rather than through continuous cycles.

Critiques and Influence

• Both Plato and Aristotle critique Anaxagoras: Plato finds his intellect lacking presence while Aristotle sees it as a fallback explanation for unexplainable phenomena.

• Despite some inaccuracies (e.g., believing Earth was flat), Anaxagoras made significant contributions to cosmology by asserting that celestial bodies like the Moon reflect sunlight rather than emit their own light.