VIDEO
HIGHLIGHT
Log InSign up
DaVinci Resolve VS Premiere Pro In 2025 - BRUTALLY Honest Comparison
SummaryTranscriptChat

DaVinci Resolve VS Premiere Pro In 2025 - BRUTALLY Honest Comparison

DaVinci Resolve vs Premiere Pro in 2025

Introduction to the Comparison

  • The video compares DaVinci Resolve and Premiere Pro across five categories, highlighting personal preferences and experiences.
  • A free guide for editing videos is offered, encouraging viewers to check it out in the description.

Stability of Software

  • Stability is emphasized as a crucial factor in editing software performance. The speaker uses both programs interchangeably.
  • Premiere Pro has improved stability but still lags behind DaVinci Resolve; issues persist with unresponsive playback during edits.
  • An example of a bug in Premiere Pro is shared, where the play button becomes unresponsive mid-editing, requiring a restart to recover work.
  • In contrast, DaVinci Resolve features "Live Save," which continuously saves edits, allowing quick recovery after crashes. This significantly enhances workflow efficiency despite occasional crashes.
  • Overall, DaVinci Resolve is deemed superior in stability due to its quick recovery capabilities compared to Premiere Pro's persistent issues.

Exporting Speed

  • Export speed is identified as another critical area where differences between the two programs are notable; time efficiency is paramount for professional editors.
  • DaVinci Resolve generally exports faster than Premiere Pro by several minutes due to its background file creation process during exportation.
  • The temporary file creation process in Premiere Pro adds extra time during exports because it duplicates files rather than moving them directly, leading to longer wait times for users.

Video Editing Software Comparison: Premiere Pro vs. DaVinci Resolve

Editing and Rendering Preferences

  • The speaker prefers editing in Premiere Pro for its ability to multitask while exporting, despite slower rendering speeds. This approach ultimately saves time when handling multiple smaller videos.
  • A suggestion is made for Blackmagic to develop a program similar to Adobe Media Encoder, potentially named Blackmagic Media Encoder or Resolve Media Encoder, which could render videos in the background.

Color Grading Capabilities

  • DaVinci Resolve is highlighted as superior in color grading compared to Premiere Pro, stemming from its origins as a dedicated color grading tool before adding editing features.
  • While professionals favor Resolve for advanced color grading, beginners may find its node-based workflow intimidating compared to the simpler interface of Premiere Pro.
  • Premiere Pro's intuitive slider-based controls make basic color adjustments easier for beginners, leveraging familiar tools from Adobe Lightroom.

User Experience and Interface

  • The speaker expresses a desire for both software programs to enhance their user interfaces: Premiere Pro should add more robust tools while Resolve could benefit from a simplified color grading panel with sliders.
  • A proposal is made for Blackmagic to introduce beginner-friendly tools on the cut page of Resolve, making it less intimidating for new editors.

Text and Captioning Features

  • Premiere Pro excels in text editing capabilities; users can easily add and customize text using keyboard shortcuts and an accessible properties menu.
  • Despite recent improvements in DaVinci Resolve's text tools, they are still considered less intuitive than those in Premiere Pro.
  • DaVinci Resolve has an advantage over Premiere Pro with animated captions feature introduced in version 20, allowing automatic generation of captions similar to TikTok.

AI Integration in Video Editing

  • Both Adobe and Blackmagic are actively integrating AI-powered tools into their software; Adobe has introduced features like media intelligence search and Generative Extend tool.
  • Concerns are raised about the current limitations of generative AI technology within these programs, including lower resolution outputs and visible glitches that detract from video quality.

Comparison of Adobe Premiere Pro and DaVinci Resolve

Generative AI Features in Video Editing

  • Adobe is charging for generative AI features, raising concerns about affordability for video editors already paying for Creative Cloud subscriptions. The sentiment suggests a perception of it being a "money grab."
  • Black Magic's DaVinci Resolve is praised for its focus on adding genuinely useful features that enhance editing without threatening jobs or creativity, addressing fears surrounding generative AI.

Impressive Updates in DaVinci Resolve 20

  • Notable new tools include an AI multicam switcher that automatically cuts between camera angles based on who is speaking, included at no extra cost compared to similar paid plugins in Premiere Pro.
  • An AI audio assistant can mix dialogue and music with one click, while an AI music beat detector places markers on beats to streamline the editing process.
  • The introduction of the AI Voice Convert tool allows users to generate a clone of a person's voice, enabling corrections to lines using the original voice—an advancement reminiscent of Adobe's abandoned Project Voco from 2016.

Overall Assessment and Future Outlook

  • The speaker believes Black Magic is currently ahead in terms of usable generative AI tools beneficial for video editors, contrasting with Adobe's approach which may evolve by 2026.
  • A comparative scoring system favors DaVinci Resolve over Premiere Pro regarding stability, color grading, and available AI tools; however, Premiere Pro excels in text editing capabilities.

Conclusion on Software Usage

  • While Resolve scores higher overall (3.5 points vs. 1.5 points), the nuances in performance categories suggest both software have unique strengths worth considering based on individual needs.
  • The speaker plans to continue using both programs due to their respective advantages and intends to learn Final Cut as well for broader skill development.
Video description

DaVinci Resolve vs Premiere Pro: which editor should you use in 2025?! I put both head to head in 5 categories and share my brutally honest thoughts about which program is best. 🌞 Get my color presets: https://courses.whoismatt.com/luts ⏩ FREE GUIDE: Edit Videos Like A Pro: https://get.whoismatt.com/editlikeapro 😍 Website Template For More Bookings!: https://creativecabana.co/matt-johnson?utm_campaign=matt_johnson&utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=video&utm_content=matt_johnson_showit_templa ❗My full list of filmmaking gear: https://kit.co/whoismatt/sony-a7s-iii-wedding-filmmaking Instagram - http://www.instagram.com/whoismatt 🎥 My friends at Bride&Groom Video would love to help you edit your wedding films! Use coupon "MATT100" for $100 off your first edit from them: https://bridengroom.video/matt/ Music licensing sites I recommend: 🎧 Sound Stripe - https://whoismatt.com/soundstripemusic (use the coupon code "WHOISMATT10" for 10% off a yearly or monthly subscription!) 🎷 ART LIST - https://whoismatt.com/artlistmusic (free extra 2-months when you subscribe using this link!) 🎵 Musicbed - https://whoismatt.com/musicbedmusic 🎤 Track Club: https://trackclub.com/referral-landing?via=whoismatt (get 1 month FREE with this link!) 🔊 Epidemic Sound: https://share.epidemicsound.com/io82zt (Free 7-Day Trial!) 🎶 Audiio: https://audiio.com/partner?oid=7&affid=892 ( Get a LIFETIME music subscription for $199 with coupon code "whoismatt199") I’m required to state that I'm a part of affiliate programs for Amazon, Artlist, Audiio, Epidemic Sound, B&H, Best Buy, Adorama, SoundStripe, Sweetwater, and Adobe and that some of the links above are affiliate links and YouTube may compensate me for using shopping tags in this video.