MAC PRO vs PC GAMER de la NASA ¿CUÁL GANA?

Comparison of Mac and PC: A Personal Experience

Introduction to the Debate

• The discussion begins with two perspectives on Macs:

• They are praised for their design and user experience.

• Criticized for being overpriced compared to custom-built PCs.

Initial Setup and Context

• The YouTuber Yulay brings the most powerful Mac available to compare it directly with a high-end gaming PC, which is significantly cheaper to build.

• The narrator mentions a promotion for Windows activation keys, highlighting affordability and ease of upgrading from Windows 10 to Windows 11.

First Impressions of macOS

• The narrator shares their first serious interaction with a Mac after years of using Windows, noting similarities in basic functions like right-clicking.

• Observations about the mouse pointer's acceleration lead to difficulties in precision, contrasting it with their experience on Windows.

User Interface Comparisons

• The absence of a traditional Start menu in macOS is noted; instead, applications are organized differently through Launchpad, reminiscent of an iPad interface.

• The top menu bar in macOS serves similar functions as in Windows but has different placements for features like WiFi and Bluetooth settings.

Hardware Observations

• Discussion about the Mac Pro 2023's specifications (M2 Ultra chip, 64GB RAM), including challenges faced when trying to restart the system due to unfamiliarity with its interface.

• Commentary on the keyboard quality reveals it feels like a low-profile membrane keyboard that lacks tactile feedback but includes a fingerprint reader.

Keyboard Design Insights

• Despite being designed differently from traditional computers, the keyboard layout remains standard (QWERTY), indicating Apple's reluctance to innovate beyond established norms.

• Mentioned price point for Apple’s official keyboard raises questions about its value relative to performance needs.

Mouse Review and Comparison with PC Gaming

Mouse Design and Ergonomics

• The mousepad's texture resembles piano black, which is prone to smudging. The design raises questions about its ergonomic suitability compared to other mice.

• The mouse is heavier than typical gaming mice, made from a metal alloy that prioritizes quality over lightness, impacting user experience.

• Features a unique touch scroll instead of a physical one, which may not meet gamers' expectations for tactile feedback during use.

• Lateral buttons are crucial for navigation and gaming; their lack of distinctiveness could hinder performance in these areas.

• Includes a USB-C port for charging and wired use; the rationale behind this design choice is questioned.

Quality Perception and Build

• The mouse's switch feels high-quality, reflecting attention to detail in its construction despite its price point of 2500 pesos.

• Notable build quality extends to accessories like HDMI cables, which are robustly designed with protective features against wear and tear.

• Overall product design shows thoughtful consideration of details that enhance user experience compared to competitors who offer only basic functionality.

Mac Pro vs. Gaming PC

• A comparison between the Mac Pro and high-end gaming PCs reveals differences in size perception; the Mac Pro appears normal next to an oversized gaming case.

• Internally, the Mac Pro has limited components; it’s larger primarily due to expansion slots rather than additional hardware capabilities.

Processor Comparisons

• Discussion on Apple's transition from Intel processors to their own M1 and M2 chips highlights significant advancements in processing power with multiple core configurations.

• The M2 Ultra chip boasts 24 cores (16 high-performance + 8 efficiency), while Intel's i9 offers fewer high-performance cores but more efficiency cores overall.

Performance Insights

• Despite differences in architecture between Apple’s M2 Ultra and Intel’s i9 processors, both deliver competitive performance levels suitable for demanding tasks.

Comparison of Mac and Gaming PC Performance

Hardware Specifications

• The Mac is equipped with a liquid cooling system and a triple fan radiator, configured with 64 GB of RAM, which can be upgraded to 196 GB.

• In contrast, the gaming PC has 128 GB of DDR5 RAM, highlighting its superior memory capacity.

• The gaming PC features an NVIDIA RTX 4090 graphics card, noted as the most powerful option available at the time.

Graphics Performance

• The Mac lacks a dedicated graphics card; it relies on an integrated GPU within the processor. This limits its graphical performance compared to dedicated GPUs in PCs.

• The integrated GPU in the Mac boasts up to 76 cores, significantly more than typical integrated GPUs in PCs that have only around 12 cores.

• Despite impressive theoretical specifications, such as teraflops, real-world performance varies greatly due to differences in operating systems and game compatibility.

Gaming Experience

• Many games are incompatible with macOS; even popular titles like Fortnite run outdated versions on Macs.

• While playing Fortnite on the Mac yielded decent performance graphically, it suffered from significant latency issues and poor peripheral responsiveness.

Input Device Limitations

• The lack of distinct right-click and left-click functionality on the Mac's touch interface complicates gameplay mechanics for shooters like Counter Strike.

• Players experienced difficulties aiming accurately due to unusual mouse sensitivity settings when using a Mac.

Benchmarking Results

• A comparative test showed that while the Mac achieved an average of 178.73 FPS in gaming scenarios, the gaming PC reached an impressive 896 FPS.

• Benchmarks indicated that both machines performed similarly in single-core processing tasks: the Mac scored 129 points while the gaming PC scored slightly higher at 130 points.

Multi-Core Performance Testing

• When tested under multi-core conditions, both computers utilized their processors at maximum capacity.

Performance Comparison: PC vs. Mac

CPU Performance and Temperature

• The gaming PC's processor reached a high temperature of 100 degrees Celsius during testing, which is becoming common for Intel's latest generations.

• In contrast, the Mac's processor maintained a much lower temperature of 73 degrees Celsius while consuming only 140 watts compared to the gaming PC's nearly 500 watts.

• The gaming PC scored 2088 points in benchmarks, while the Mac scored 1930 points, indicating that although the PC won, it did so under significant thermal stress.

GPU Testing Insights

• When testing with the GPU, results showed a stark difference; the gaming PC produced significantly lower noise and temperatures below 60 degrees Celsius.

• The gaming PC consumed around 400 watts while the Mac used less than half that amount but achieved an impressive score of 8571 points against the gaming PC’s RTX 4090 score of 34951 points.

• Overall benchmarks indicated that while CPU performance was slightly better on the gaming PC, its GPU consistently outperformed that of the Mac by a large margin.

Adobe Premiere Performance

• Adobe Premiere serves as an interesting test case since it utilizes all components (CPU, GPU, RAM, storage), making it sensitive to any weaknesses in hardware.

• The speaker opens a complex video project in Premiere to demonstrate editing performance differences between systems; this project is notably heavy without optimizations like proxies.

• Despite some minor playback issues on both systems, editing on the Mac felt smoother compared to Windows due to faster loading times and transitions.

Editing Experience Comparison

• Although optimized for performance, even a well-tuned Windows setup struggled with fluidity when editing heavy projects compared to using a Mac.

• The speaker suggests that deep optimizations within Adobe Premiere and macOS contribute significantly to smoother editing experiences on Macs over PCs.

• Personal investment in hardware improvements has not equaled the smoothness experienced on Macs during video editing tasks.

Rendering Speed Test

• A rendering speed test was conducted using identical projects on both computers; both were set at equal quality levels for comparison purposes.

• Initially appearing as if the more powerful graphics card in the gaming PC would finish first during rendering tests; however, surprisingly, it was outpaced by the Mac Pro.

• This outcome highlights how raw power does not always translate into better performance across different software environments.

Conclusion: Choosing Between Systems

• Building an optimal gaming PC is ideal for those seeking cost-effective high-performance solutions for gaming and general use.

Video Editing Hardware Considerations

Evaluating Video Editing Performance

• The speaker discusses the importance of having a powerful and fast machine for video editing, emphasizing that speed is crucial for efficiency.

• They express that with faster editing capabilities, they would experience less stress and be able to produce more videos.

• The speaker reflects on their past investment in a Mac, suggesting that they might not choose the Mac Pro again due to its high cost and limited advantages.

• They mention the only significant benefit of the Mac Pro being its expansion slots, which may not justify the expense.