铁链女事件，一个迎合民意情绪的荒唐判决｜铁链女｜董总志民｜八孩母｜精神疾病｜救助｜舆论风暴｜宣判｜王局拍案20230410

The Case of the Chained Woman

This transcript discusses the verdict in the case of a woman who was chained up and fathered eight children with her husband, Dong Zhimin.

Dong Zhimin's Sentence

• Dong Zhimin was sentenced to 9 years in prison for illegal imprisonment and abuse.

• Many people thought that his sentence was too lenient considering the severity of his crimes.

• The verdict sparked public outcry on China's internet.

Villagers' Reactions

• It is likely that villagers from Dong and chained woman's village would find the verdict absurd since they may not understand city folks' world.

• Most families have some restraints on their mentally ill family members, which is common in China.

Analysis of Verdict

Folk Customary Law vs Statutory Law

• The verdict shows how statutory law has raped Chinese folk customary law.

• False imprisonment charge is far-fetched since it is extremely common in families with mentally ill members.

Abuse Charge

• There are two main things identified as abuse: loss of teeth and chaining her up.

Introduction

The speaker discusses the context of a case involving a mentally ill woman who was chained up by her family and the subsequent public outcry that led to the family being arrested.

Mental Illness in China

• Many families keep mentally ill people at home without clothes.

• There are probably at least a few hundred thousand severely mentally ill people in China.

• Most cases of intra-family abuse involve mothers abusing their children, resulting in low sentences.

Case Overview

• A live streamer on Douyin visited Dong Zhimin's home and saw his wife, who had mental illness, chained up.

• The live streamer published this online, which led to public outrage and government intervention.

• Dong Zhimin was arrested for chaining up his wife.

Background Information

The speaker provides background information on Little Huamei, the woman who was chained up by her family.

Little Huamei's Story

• Little Huamei is mentally ill and was sent back to her parents after being married off to someone else.

• Sang from Yunnan offered to take care of Little Huamei and bring her to Jiangsu.

• After living with Xu Moudong for three or four months, Little Huamei went missing.

• She was found 300 kilometers away in Henan a month later.

Conclusion

The speaker concludes by discussing how the verdict in this case is a dismemberment of the life of the Chinese underclass by civilized society and spiritual abuse.

Verdict Analysis

• The high sentence imposed on Dong Zhimin is difficult to justify given that most cases of intra-family abuse result in low sentences.

• People who criticize Dong Zhimin's actions may not understand the struggles faced by those living in the Chinese underclass.

• The verdict is a dismemberment of the life of the Chinese underclass by civilized society and spiritual abuse.

The Trafficking of Women and the Rights of Mental Illness

This section discusses the trafficking of women and the rights of mental illness in China's rural society.

Trafficking of Women

• Many women are targeted, raped, or sold due to social realities in China.

• Little Huamei was sold by a couple who took her in to the Huo brothers for 3,000 yuan. She was then sold to Dong Zhimin and his father where she lived with Dong and gave birth to eight children until news broke.

Rights of Mental Illness

• There are two main aspects: trafficking of women and rights of mental illness.

• The government has no power to punish when it doesn't have the ability to bail out. Mental illnesses are a large group in China with 5.8 million people suffering from it.

• Rural families cannot afford medical care for mental illnesses which can lead to long-term medical care costs that never end. Families often do not treat mental illness well due to financial considerations.

• Mentally ill individuals may be chained up like animals or sold off as they have no reproductive value. Families at the bottom of rural society think that if these women can marry someone, there is someone who will take care of them and provide food.

• Providing some level of mental care is necessary for basic protection but many families cannot assume this obligation alone.

Factors Affecting Mental Illness Rights

• Economic development determines whether society can integrate mental illness into government jurisdiction which depends on financial resources. Poor societies cannot do this.

• Social security also plays a role in the level of mental illness rights. Historically, in all Chinese dynasties, mental illness was not treated as human beings and were often killed by lynching.

The Role of the Government in Providing Social Security for Mentally Ill People

In this section, the speaker discusses the responsibility of the government in providing social security for mentally ill people.

The Importance of Government Support

• Prior to the last decade, families of mentally ill people were financially overwhelmed due to lack of health insurance coverage.

• With medical insurance coverage, mentally ill patients can be sent to psychiatric hospitals and their survival has improved. However, families may still refuse to let them leave the hospital.

• The speaker believes that it is the government's responsibility to provide social security for mentally ill people and protect their human rights. Without adequate support from the government, families cannot be expected to provide sufficient protection.

Punishing Families vs. Providing Support

• The speaker argues that if a family is unable to provide adequate human rights protection for a mentally ill person despite government support, then punishment may be justified.

• However, punishing families without providing social security is not justifiable as it does not address the root cause of inadequate protection.

Difficulties in Rescuing Trafficked Women

In this section, the speaker discusses difficulties in rescuing trafficked women and how it relates to government support.

Reasons Why Women May Not Want To Be Rescued

• Women who have been trafficked may resist rescue because they may have better economic conditions or a good husband where they are currently living.

• Additionally, some women may have children which makes leaving difficult.

Importance of Government Support in Rescue Efforts

• If the government cannot provide enough support to trafficked women, then it has no right to demand that they be rescued.

• The speaker argues that the purpose of rescue is not to make people's lives more miserable. If women are rescued but their families do not accept them and society discriminates against them, then the rescue effort has failed.

The Importance of Providing Support Before Punishment

In this section, the speaker discusses the importance of providing support before punishment. He argues that punishing individuals who commit crimes due to poverty is not effective and that society should focus on providing a support system for neglected groups.

Compulsory Education Law and Project Hope

• China's Compulsory Education Law was implemented over a decade ago, but many children were still out of school.

• The government must make education free and waive all tuition and fees to ensure that every child has access to education.

• Punishing parents for not sending their children to school is not justifiable if they cannot afford it.

• A support system must be provided first before punishment can be enforced.

Society's Power to Help Neglected Groups

• If a crime is caused by poverty, society has no power to punish it. Instead, society should provide help.

• The government should have helped Dong Zhimin's family instead of punishing them when Little Huamei was resold.

• Arresting Dong Zhimin and taking Little Huamei to a mental hospital does not solve the problem or bring justice.

Sang's Story

• Sang was abducted and sold into marriage in Jiangsu Province. She did not leave her family despite having the opportunity to do so.

• At least one million families were married through similar means in Jiangsu Province alone, with an estimated total of 10 million families across China.

Overall, the speaker emphasizes the need for a support system for neglected groups rather than punishment. He also highlights the prevalence of poverty-driven crimes in China and the importance of socio-economic development to address this issue.

The Chained Woman

This section discusses the opposing arguments online regarding a man's right to buy a wife, and how the situation of Little Huamei, the chained woman, improved after being sold to Dong's family.

Arguments Online

• One argument is that a male bachelor looking for a wife in the countryside is also a human right. If he can't find a normal wife, he can buy one.

• The opposing side believes that women's rights have nothing to do with men not being able to find a wife. You can't buy another woman as your wife just because you can't find one.

• The perspective of this argument may be problematic.

Improving Little Huamei's Situation

• Little Huamei's situation improved when she was sold to Dong's family.

• If she hadn't been sold, she would probably be wandering the streets and could have been raped or abused.

• This indicates the lack of responsibility of society and government in rescuing mentally ill people like her.

Restrain Your Moral Impulses

This section advises netizens to restrain their moral impulses when facing tragic social events online and consider more from the perspective of those involved.

Facing Tragic Social Events Online

• Netizens should try to restrain their moral impulses when facing tragic social events online.

• They should consider more from the perspective of those involved rather than satisfying their own sense of morality.

• Sometimes moral demands may punish those involved instead of helping them.

Mental Illness Case Study

This section shares an interview with a mother whose son was mentally ill and highlights the challenges faced by families dealing with mental illness.

Mother's Story

• A mother raised money and sent her mentally ill son to a psychiatric hospital.

• After treatment, her son recovered and wanted to go home but refused to take medication.

• He got sick again and had to be sent back to the hospital for treatment.

• This cycle repeated several times, causing the mother to have a nervous breakdown.

A Mother's Suffering

The speaker shares a story about a mother who couldn't bear to refuse her mentally ill son food, despite the difficulties she faced.

A Desperate Mother

• The mother left food in the hospital doctor's office every time she went to see her son.

• The speaker empathizes with the suffering of family members of mentally ill people and highlights the need for more understanding and knowledge.

• The mother wanted to let her son out but didn't dare.

Verdict on Chained Woman Case

The speaker discusses the verdict on a case involving a chained woman and reflects on poverty and social security.

Tragedy Caused by Poverty

• The verdict is nothing but an appeal to public opinion to show that the government is right, and there is no justice in itself.

• Dong Zhimin, who brought Little Huamei to his home, was not sentenced leniently but too heavily.

• Poverty and insufficient social security caused this tragedy.

Forced Rescue Not Justified

• Punishment or rescue is only justified if it improves the interests of the person concerned.

• As an onlooker, refrain from demanding people involved with their own situation as it creates secondary harm.

Sentencing Details

This section provides details about sentencing in relation to the chained woman case.

Sentencing Information

• Defendant Dong Zhimin was sentenced to six years and six months in prison.

• Defendant Dong Zhimin was guilty of false imprisonment and sentenced to three years in prison.

• The defendant was sentenced to nine years' imprisonment.