The Problem with Stainless Steel

The Uster Pool Collapse: A Lesson in Stainless Steel Failure

The Tragic Event

• On May 9, 1985, a tragic incident occurred in Uster, Switzerland, when the ceiling of a local swimming pool collapsed unexpectedly.

• The collapse resulted in twelve fatalities and numerous injuries among the approximately forty swimmers present at the time.

• Investigators quickly identified corroded stainless steel rods as the cause of the structural failure.

Understanding Stainless Steel Corrosion

• The disaster highlighted an important truth: despite being labeled "stainless," these materials are not immune to corrosion.

• Stainless steel is primarily an alloy of iron and carbon, with chromium being a crucial element that enhances its corrosion resistance.

Role of Chromium in Stainless Steel

• Chromium atoms replace some iron atoms in stainless steel and bond with oxygen to form a protective layer called chromium oxide. This layer is only about ten atoms thick but effectively prevents rusting by blocking moisture and oxygen from reaching the iron beneath it.

• This oxide layer can self-heal if damaged, provided that there is sufficient chromium content (at least 10.5% by weight) for effective protection against corrosion.

Crystal Structures of Iron

• Iron can exist in two main crystal structures: body-centered cubic (BCC) known as ferrite, and face-centered cubic (FCC) known as austenite; temperature influences this transformation significantly.

• In stainless steels, alloying elements like chromium stabilize these structures differently—chromium stabilizes BCC while nickel stabilizes FCC structures during cooling processes.

Types of Stainless Steels

• Ferritic stainless steels contain more chromium and are magnetic due to their BCC structure; they tend to be less expensive but harder to work with compared to austenitic grades which are non-magnetic and more ductile due to their FCC structure.

• Austenitic stainless steels like grade 304 (18% chromium, 8% nickel) were used for the Uster pool's suspension rods because of their excellent formability and corrosion resistance; grade 316 offers even better localized corrosion resistance due to added molybdenum.

Understanding Stainless Steel Grades and Their Properties

Overview of Stainless Steel Grades

• Grade 430 contains 16 to 18% chromium with minimal nickel content.

• Austenitic stainless steels dominate global production, comprising about 70%, while ferritic grades account for 25%.

• Martensitic and duplex stainless steels represent smaller segments at 4% and 1%, respectively.

• Martensitic steels have higher carbon levels than ferritic steels, leading to austenite formation at elevated temperatures.

Transformation Processes in Stainless Steels

• Slow cooling of martensitic steel results in ferrite formation; rapid cooling aims for martensite, yielding high strength.

• Duplex stainless steels feature a nickel content between austenitic and ferritic grades, enhancing their strength due to a two-phase structure.

Mechanical Properties Comparison

• Yield strength is plotted against elongation to compare mechanical properties across different stainless steel types.

• Austenitic steels show moderate yield strength but high elongation; cold working increases yield strength but reduces ductility.

• Ferritic steels have comparable yield strengths to annealed austenitics but lower elongation, limiting their formability.

Precipitation-Hardened (PH) Steels

• PH steels can be martensitic or austenitic and include elements like copper or aluminum that enhance strength through aging processes.

• The most common PH steel is 17-4 PH, which incorporates copper for fine dispersion of strengthening precipitates during heat treatment.

Corrosion Issues in Uster Pool: A Case Study

Corrosion Mechanisms in Stainless Steel

• Grade 304 was selected for its corrosion resistance but failed due to aggressive environmental conditions above the suspended ceiling.

• Warm humid air carried chlorinated compounds that concentrated on the stainless steel rods over time, leading to pitting corrosion.

Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC)

• Pitting corrosion initiated stress corrosion cracking (SCC), requiring three factors: susceptible material, corrosive environment, and tensile stress.

• The suspension rods experienced sustained tensile stress from both weight and manufacturing residual stresses, exacerbating crack formation.

Consequences of SCC

• Microscopic cracks formed preferentially within corrosion pits acted as stress concentrators; plastic deformation ruptured protective films allowing further attack by chlorides.

• Elevated temperatures increased the likelihood of chloride-induced SCC; hidden rods went unchecked until failure occurred during collapse.

Investigation Findings

• Post-collapse investigations revealed significant damage: out of 207 rods, 108 fractured with evidence of chloride-induced SCC.

Understanding Stress Corrosion Cracking in Austenitic Stainless Steels

Susceptibility to Stress Corrosion Cracking

• Austenitic stainless steels are highly susceptible to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) in chloride environments due to their face-centered cubic structure, which allows for easier dislocation movement.

• The close packing of atoms in austenitic structures means that local plastic deformation can occur at lower stress levels compared to body-centered cubic (BCC) structures, contributing to higher ductility.

Mechanisms of Crack Growth

• The plastic deformation at the tip of a developing crack leads to continuous rupture of the chromium oxide film, facilitating further crack growth and increasing vulnerability to SCC.

• 304 stainless steel's low Pitting Resistance Equivalent Number (PREN), due to limited molybdenum and nitrogen content, makes it more prone to pitting corrosion, which can initiate stress corrosion cracking.

Historical Context and Engineering Changes

• The Uster disaster highlighted the need for better specifications for stainless steel in chloride-rich environments; previously, SCC was thought only possible under extreme conditions.

• Today, duplex stainless steels are preferred for structural applications in challenging environments because their two-phase microstructure significantly enhances resistance to SCC while providing better strength and toughness than fully ferritic steels.

Lessons from Failures

• Several pool failures throughout the 1990s and 2000s were attributed to SCC in austenitic stainless steels, emphasizing the importance of material selection based on environmental context.

• Engineers must recognize that material behavior is influenced by various design choices that may interact unexpectedly; thus, careful consideration during design phases is crucial.

Importance of Prototyping and Testing

• Effective engineering requires recognizing critical assumptions about material behavior and real-world performance; this may involve prototyping or simulations early in the design process.

Introduction to Onshape: A Cloud-Based CAD Solution

Features of Onshape

• Onshape is a cloud-based CAD platform offering core functionalities like parametric part modeling and assemblies without traditional installation hassles; everything operates directly from a web browser.

• Collaboration is enhanced as models stored in the cloud allow access from any device, enabling easy sharing for design reviews with specialists who can work simultaneously on projects.

Version Control and Efficiency

• Built-in version tracking records every change made within models, allowing users to see modifications over time easily; this feature supports efficient engineering practices with improved traceability.

• The Professional plan includes advanced features such as simulation capabilities and unlimited private cloud storage tailored for commercial use while protecting intellectual property rights.