How to Value Crypto Tokens: Fees, Flows or Fugazi | Roundup
Introduction
The co-hosts introduce themselves and give a disclaimer before discussing the week's topics.
Co-Hosts Introduction
- Michael, Michael, and Vance introduce themselves as co-hosts of the podcast.
- They give a disclaimer that their personal views do not represent any organization they are associated with.
- They also clarify that nothing in the episode should be construed as financial, technical, tax, legal or other advice.
Block Works Investment
- Michael and Vance disclose that they are now investors in Block Works.
- The co-hosts discuss how quickly Block Works is growing and express excitement to be part of it.
Weekly Topics
The co-hosts discuss interesting events from the past week.
Aragon Controversy
- Aragon is a project that has developed various software products including Aragon Court for Dow governance.
- There have been allegations of mismanagement of funds by Aragon Foundation leading to some funds buying up Aragon tokens to push for a vote to return capital immediately.
- The vote passed successfully but just before it was about to happen, Aragon Foundation took all the money and called the process of voting a 51 attack on democracy.
- Some funds lost money due to this event.
Decentralization Theater
In this section, the speaker discusses the issue of decentralization in crypto projects and how recent events have exposed some of the flaws in this concept.
Decentralization and Investment Strategy
- The treasury of a project should be delivered back to the community or users of the protocol when it is complete.
- Recent events have unmasked some of the decentralization theater that happens in early-stage projects.
Aragon's Governance Token
- Aragon did a bad job establishing value for their governance token, ANT.
- The value of ANT fell below the treasury value, which led to Aragon buying tokens and wrapping them quickly to give voting rights.
- They voted for pro-rata distribution of the treasury back to token holders so they could make money, but Aragon changed its governance mode claiming a 51% attack.
Two Phases of Governance
- There are two phases of governance: Snapshot and Multi-sig.
- Snapshot is not connected to a Smart contract; it's more like a polling mechanism.
- You need someone with multi-sig or unilateral control over all assets to go do something.
Activist Investing Model vs Warren Buffett Investing Model
- The activist investing model takes companies with great products, huge TAM, passionate audience/community/user base, cash flow positive but misaligned management/employees.
- Warren Buffet's investing model looks for things trading below their residual/cash value.
- The leap here is that you assume you can recover more than what you paid for an asset/token/governance token by taking advantage of misalignment/mismanagement.
Overall, this section discusses the issue of decentralization in crypto projects and how recent events have exposed some of the flaws in this concept. The speaker also talks about Aragon's governance token, two phases of governance, and different investing models.
Aragon's Token and Customer Set
In this section, the speakers discuss Aragon's token and customer set. They talk about how Aragon lost track of who their customers were a long time ago, and how their mission and values are completely killed.
Aragon's Token
- The token market cap was 110 million, but their treasury is 185 million.
- There is a huge mismatch between the two.
- If you're invested in Aragon, your upside is you make 1X, but your downside is you lose everything 1X.
- There's no asymmetry there, and chances are you're going to get rugged.
Customer Set
- Aragon lost track of who their customers were a long time ago.
- Their mission and values are completely killed which kills that customer set.
- If Aragon didn't have a token, they could have just been a sick SAS company where they just built really good products and charged people 20K a year increased it as the seats went up.
Treasury Management
In this section, the speakers discuss treasury management. They talk about how most of their treasury would be in their native token but they actually did a much better job than most thousand diversifying.
Treasury Management
- Most of their treasury would be in their native token but they actually did a much better job than most thousand diversifying.
- This is like a top five percent of bad treasury management.
- The ideas that come to people in Bear markets when they're like oh we should go after this person and get their money because like they're not spending it wisely and like it kind of never seems to work.
Imposter Syndrome in Web3
In this section, the speakers discuss imposter syndrome in web3. They talk about how people want to replicate Warren Buffett's investment strategy and be those things in web3.
Imposter Syndrome in Web3
- People want to replicate Warren Buffett's investment strategy and be those things in web3.
- There is an imposter syndrome of oh I want to be able to go off and extract value from like 125 to 185 and it just doesn't work the same way.
- Frankly, they haven't seen a repeatable process that works.
- Hindenburg's latest target is actually Carl icon company where there are allegations of him inflating asset values that are liquid.
Carl Icahn's Scheme
In this section, the speaker discusses Carl Icahn's scheme and how he has not answered Hindenburg's questions. He continues to increase his pledges of shares against these margin loans, and the terms of the loans are undisclosed.
Carl Icahn's Scheme
- Carl Icahn has not answered Hindenburg's questions.
- He continues to increase his pledges of shares against these margin loans.
- The terms of the loans are undisclosed.
- The speaker wonders how many times other people have run this same scheme.
Billionaires Running the Same Playbook
In this section, the speaker talks about billionaires running the same playbook as Carl Icahn. They discuss Bill Ackman and his fight with Icon Enterprises over Herbalife.
Billionaires Running the Same Playbook
- Many billionaires have run this playbook before.
- Bill Ackman had a fight with Icon Enterprises over Herbalife.
- One of the most epic moments in financial media was when Ackman went on CNBC and then Icon joined the call.
Druckenmiller Speech and Crypto Preview
In this section, the speaker talks about Druckenmiller's speech and how it resonated with him. They also discuss crypto as a preview for Trad fight.
Druckenmiller Speech and Crypto Preview
- Druckenmiller gave a great speech that resonated with the speaker.
- When there are zero interest rates for 11 years, people make really dumb decisions.
- Crypto is a preview for Trad fight.
- We are still on cleanup duty for the past two years.
Mopping Up
In this section, the speaker talks about mopping up and how everything is so shaky and frenzied. They discuss how Carl Icahn is taking it in the teeth.
Mopping Up
- Everything is so shaky and frenzied.
- Carl Icahn is taking it in the teeth.
Commemorative T-Shirt and Crypto Proposals
In this section, the speakers discuss a commemorative t-shirt they received and then move on to talk about two big proposals that went live in crypto.
Arbitrum Proposal for Distribution of Dow Revenue
- The proposal is to distribute a portion of the accumulated revenue from the Arbitrum Dow to ARB token holders.
- The distribution of revenue will be proportionate to the amount of ARB tokens delegated by each holder.
- Benefits include distributing Dow revenue to ARB token holders, aligning community incentives, creating a more engaged user base, and giving ARB a purpose beyond just being a governance token.
- The speakers note that Block Works is a big delegate for Arbitrum and disclose that their opinions are not indicative of anything related to Block Works.
Turning on V-Switches and Sharing Fees
- The Overton window is moving towards turning on v-switches or sharing fees generally, which is positive for the industry.
- Real economics flowing through the Dow or Token itself is important for future success.
- Entrepreneurs are still willing to launch tokens and turn on v-switches despite regulatory pressure because they believe in decentralization.
- Decentralized protocols with self-sustaining models will be key for future decentralized networks.
Importance of Token Models
- Token models incentivize usage and attract users to platforms. Without them, centralized providers cannot compete with decentralized opportunities.
- A framework is being developed in Capitol Hill to build decentralized networks in the US without regulatory pressure.
- Decentralized networks will be the mainstay of future networks.
Capital Allocation and Token Value
In this section, the speakers discuss the allocation of capital in projects and how it affects token value. They also talk about the implications of returning capital to token holders.
Capital Allocation Question
- The speakers discuss the importance of capital allocation in projects.
- Dividends or share buybacks are not productive uses of capital if there are better ways to create value for the project.
- Returning capital to token holders can be problematic because it creates an expectation that cannot be easily stopped.
Token Value Based on Flows
- The speakers discuss how tokens are valued based on flows rather than fundamentals like revenue or earnings.
- Having a token economic model that enables additional buying or purchasing of the token itself from the treasury becomes valuable when there is a lot of cash flow flowing to the token.
- Tokens like ETH earn a lot of revenue, but no other asset has hit that scale yet.
Valuing Early Stage Startups
In this section, the speakers compare valuing early stage startups with valuing tokens based on flows.
Comparing Valuation Methods
- The speakers compare valuing early stage startups with valuing tokens based on flows.
- Investors do not necessarily underwrite early stage SAS companies based on metrics like price-to-sales or price-to-earnings ratios.
Valuation Framework for Crypto Companies
In this section, the speakers discuss the valuation framework for crypto companies and how it differs from traditional markets. They also talk about the need for a more efficient marketplace and rational valuation framework.
Valuing Crypto Companies
- As soon as you move past the series A, people value crypto companies based on price to revenue and potential for profit.
- Financial infrastructure around startups and publicly traded stocks is not valuing these things based on fundamentals.
- The most efficient inefficient markets that we've ever seen.
- We're trending towards a more efficient marketplace, but we need structural flow to have a rational valuation framework.
Investor Base
- The lack of an evaluation framework in crypto is due to its mostly retail investor base.
- Traditional markets have ranges and indexes that they look at for PE multiples and thresholds.
- Infrastructure doesn't exist yet to understand metrics like T5 Lava or Token Terminal.com.
Structural Flow in Crypto Markets
In this section, the speakers discuss how structural flow can lead to a more rational valuation framework in crypto markets.
Rational Valuation Framework
- Once flows confirm metrics, there will be a more rational valuation framework.
- Maker currently trades in a tight range of 20 to 30 priced earnings because it buys back tokens.
- Need structural flow if you're a serious project coming into the next run.
Passive Buyers vs Active Traders
- People who trade stocks or commodities are passive buyers who trade based on if it gets cheap or expensive.
- Crypto needs active traders who think about gross margins, fees, etc. when trading.
UniSwap V-Switch Proposal
In this section, the speakers discuss the UniSwap V-Switch proposal.
UniSwap V-Switch
- GFX proposed turning on the V-switch this week.
- The speakers do not know if they took a look at it.
I apologize, but I cannot see any transcript or video to summarize. Please provide me with the necessary information so that I can create a comprehensive and informative markdown file for you.
Uniflop's Proposal
The discussion is about Uniflop's proposal and the technical difficulties involved in implementing it. They are testing it out on Polygon first, which is a smart move due to lower TV volume. There is uncertainty about whether liquidity will migrate off of Uniswap at some point.
Technical Difficulties
- Implementing Uniflop's proposal is technically challenging, especially for B3.
- Testing the proposal on Polygon first is a good idea due to lower TV volume.
Uncertainty About Liquidity Migration
- It is uncertain whether liquidity will migrate off of Uniswap at some point.
- Long ill pep-based style coins are where Uniswap does well, while blue chip coins are where their fees are generally highest.
Community Support for Uniflop's Proposal
The discussion centers around the importance of community support for addressing issues related to liquidity venues. Getting money into the Dow and tokens is seen as the first step towards this goal.
Importance of Community Support
- A strong community that can help address issues related to liquidity venues will be super important at some point.
- UniSwap lacks a strong community that can help them race through all these issues.
Steps Towards Addressing Issues Related to Liquidity Venues
- Getting money into the Dow and tokens is seen as the first step towards addressing issues related to liquidity venues.
- The landscape regarding liquidity venues will change over the next few years.
Gfx Labs' Proposal
The discussion is about Gfx Labs' proposal and the technical difficulties involved in implementing it. Tax and legal concerns are seen as major hurdles to getting the proposal over the finish line.
Technical Difficulties
- Gfx Labs' proposal is seen as having some legs due to their expertise in Uniswap.
- There are lots of complications involved in implementing the proposal, including tax and legal concerns.
Hurdles to Getting Proposal Over the Finish Line
- Tax and legal concerns have made it difficult to get Gfx Labs' proposal over the finish line.
- It's unclear how taxes would work if the Dow itself starts accruing revenue.
Future Proposals for Liquidity Venues
The discussion centers around future proposals related to liquidity venues. There is uncertainty about what these proposals will entail, but they may address issues related to commodities becoming securities or what constitutes decentralization.
Future Proposals for Liquidity Venues
- There will likely be future proposals related to liquidity venues that address issues such as commodities becoming securities or what constitutes decentralization.
- No further bullet points available.
Operating from the US and Regulatory Side
The speaker discusses the challenges of operating from the US and regulatory issues related to governance tokens.
Challenges of Operating from the US
- It is challenging to operate from the US, especially with one or both hands tied behind your back.
Regulatory Issues Related to Governance Tokens
- The speaker's company delegates voting on their behalf to different entities, such as blockchain clubs at universities.
- They do not tell these entities how they want them to vote.
Hiring a Podcast Producer
The speaker announces that they are hiring a podcast producer for their crypto side.
Details about the Job
- The job involves overseeing a show, sourcing and scheduling guests, planning and researching episodes, crafting content post-production, etc.
- Candidates should have a deep understanding of crypto, D5 NFTs, etc.
- Interested candidates should apply through their careers page.
Mev Bot Jared from Subway
The speaker talks about Mev bot Jared from Subway and shares some insights into how it works.
Insights into How Mev Bot Jared Works
- Jared makes money sandwiching traders on Pepe meme coin using an interesting strategy.
- Jared's inventory approach is different from other bots in that he starts with a whole bunch of supply of Pepe token instead of starting with eth.
- Jared uses a unique strategy of mega sandwiching, putting more trades into the sandwich than just a one-one-one.
Mev Bot Jared from Subway - Case Study
The speaker shares a case study of how Mev bot Jared works.
Case Study of How Mev Bot Jared Works
- Robert Miller shares some insights into how Jared makes money sandwiching traders on Pepe meme coin.
- Jared's inventory approach is different from other bots in that he starts with a whole bunch of supply of Pepe token instead of starting with eth.
- Jared uses a unique strategy of mega sandwiching, putting more trades into the sandwich than just a one-one-one.
Meb's Turning Back on Crazy Coins
In this section, the speakers discuss the recent activity and engagement on Pepe and how it indicates the green shoots of what this bear market is. They also talk about how Meb is going to be a benefactor for all of that.
Signs of Green Shoots
- Recent activity and engagement on Pepe indicate the green shoots of what this bear market is.
- Meb is going to be a benefactor for all of that.
Difficulty in Doing as an Institution
- It's difficult for institutions from the United States to do that.
- The builder market in general is opaque, and rule of law hasn't been applied to MEV up till now.
Insider Trading
- If you were a builder with access to order flow and trading using that information, does it constitute material non-public information?
- You could make a case for insider trading.
- Compliance or legal may have said they could be at risk here; it's probably not worth it.
Flowing Somewhere Else
- If you block one direction, then it will just flow somewhere else.
- People searching are not just going to give up; someone will continue forward where they left off.
Large Builders Required
- The e-scaling roadmap implicitly requires larger, more sophisticated builders.
- You need a builder who understands state to stand in front of dumb pipes that do sequencing.
- The more order flow you see, the better you'll be at winning blocks.
Crypto Market Makers
- If market makers pull out, there will be crypto-native market makers to step in.
- Big crypto Market crypto native market makers developing themselves is better than anything else.
Market Opportunity for Crypto Native Market Makers
In this section, the speakers discuss the potential market opportunity for crypto native market makers.
Crypto Native Market Maker
- There is a huge market opportunity to be a crypto native market maker.
- Different models for market making exist, including traditional models and token call option models.
- The token call option model of market making may not be scalable in the long term.
Conclusion
- The speakers agree that there is a need for crypto native market makers but caution against relying on non-scalable models.
- They end the discussion and wrap up the video.
Turn any video into a summary like this
YouTube links, meetings, lectures. With transcripts, search, and chat.