Islam Between East and West with Dr. Sherman Jackson & Ustadh Ubaydullah Evans
Introduction
The speaker welcomes the audience and makes a few announcements about upcoming programs.
- Winter program registration is open, and it will take place on MLK weekend in Virginia.
- Summer program registration is also open, and it will take place at Benedictine University in Chicago.
- Scholarships are available for both programs.
- Donations can be made to the Giving Tuesday campaign through alanprogram.org.
Book Discussion
The speaker discusses the book "Islam between East and West" by Alija Izetbegovic.
- The book was recommended for the book club because of its approach to integrating Islam into important issues of the day.
- The author was able to engage with European thought without being in a reactionary mode.
- He was critical but not alienated from Islamic tradition while thoroughly versed in European tradition.
The Role of Young Muslims in Society
In this section, the speakers discuss how young Muslims can engage with society and use the book as a model for grappling with similar issues.
Approaches to Engage in Society
- The book can serve as a model for young Muslims to approach engagement with society.
- The author is rewriting the traditional approach of Islamic scholarship and writing from an interdisciplinary perspective.
- The author's broad learning and interdisciplinary approach make him unique in our time.
Writing as an Islamic Scholar
In this section, the speakers discuss whether or not the author is writing as an Islamic scholar and his interdisciplinary approach.
Writing Style
- The author is not writing strictly as an art historian or historian but rather as someone of broad learning.
- Although his thought differs from classical Islamic scholars, he is still writing as an Islamic thinker.
- His interdisciplinary approach allows him to comfortably talk about various subjects such as art history, literature, and natural sciences.
Islam Beyond Scholarship
In this section, the speakers discuss how Islam itself is not limited to scholarship and that one does not have to be a scholar to be an Islamic scholar.
Division of Labor
- There is now a stricter division of labor in terms of what one can speak about with authority.
- One does not have to be a formally trained scholar to be considered an Islamic scholar.
The Bipolarity of Islam
In this section, the speaker discusses how Islam is a synthesis between Judaism and Christianity. He talks about the bipolarity of Islam and how it focuses on both the social and political aspects as well as the internal life of human beings.
The Bipolarity of Islam
- Islam is a synthesis between Judaism and Christianity.
- Islam has a bipolarity that focuses on both the social and political aspects as well as the internal life of human beings.
- Christianity emphasizes the internal life of human beings while Judaism has a certain externality to it.
- Islam encourages its adherents to cultivate a longing for the next life while not shunning bodily pleasure or appetite.
Religion in Modern World
In this section, the speaker talks about how religion in modern times has been reduced to only its spiritual dimension. He also discusses how Muslims have internalized this notion, which keeps them from being able to compete on a global scale.
Religion in Modern World
- Religion in modern times has been reduced to only its spiritual dimension.
- The entire modern world has internalized this notion that religion is relevant almost strictly to the spirit.
- Muslims have also internalized this idea that they must move away from Islam in order to dedicate their energies towards materialistic pursuits such as technology, war, and economic instruments.
- This notion keeps Muslims stagnated because they are unable to compete on a global scale due to their lack of development in these areas.
Modern Atheism and the Inner Callings of the Human Self
In this section, the speaker discusses how modern atheism is not sustainable because it cannot address or fulfill the inner callings of the human self. Traditional religion has lost balance between spiritual and material aspects, leading to unsatisfactory results. The speaker argues that Islam recognizes the dual dimension of human beings and attempts to establish, cultivate, and maintain that balance.
Dual Dimension of Human Beings
- Islam recognizes the dual dimension of human beings as both spiritual and material.
- The point of Islam is to effectively address both material side of life while not ignoring one's inner self.
- Living fully on one hand and righteously on the other is a challenge that Marxism, communism, socialism focus on social justice while Christianity focuses exclusively on spirituality.
- Islam combines both spiritual and material aspects.
Religion Losing Balance
- Religion has lost balance between spiritual and material aspects.
- We are both material and spiritual beings; denying either aspect leads to an imbalance.
- Almost all religions have some concept or value idea of salvation which points towards our transcendent aspect beyond just physical existence.
Seeking Transcendence
- Seeking transcendence is what humans have done since we recognized ourselves as humans.
- There is a profound Hadith from Prophet Muhammad about seeking metaphysical understanding.
The Material and Spiritual Dimensions of Life
In this section, the speaker discusses how both the material and spiritual dimensions of life cannot be denied. He also talks about how human beings have an ingrained desire to produce and create, but are also anxious beings.
The Importance of Addressing Material Dimensions
- Success is achieved by addressing the material dimensions of life.
- Both the spiritual and material dimensions cannot be denied.
Human Desire to Produce
- Humans have an ingrained desire to use their hands and minds to make a print on the world.
- This desire is seen in children's interest in playing.
Anxiety in Society
- American society is currently experiencing high levels of anxiety.
- There are no programs for managing this anxiety.
Religion and Anxiety
- Anxiety is a defining characteristic of human beings.
- Religion can help manage anxiety.
- If religion does not address this dimension of the human condition, it will likely be exploited.
Religion as Tied to Afterlife?
In this section, the speaker discusses whether religion is necessarily tied to the afterlife or if it can also focus on materiality.
Arabian Religion
- Arabian religion was not tied to the afterlife.
- They had rituals that focused on materiality, such as worshiping idols for protection from natural forces.
Culture vs Civilization
In this section, the speakers discuss the difference between culture and civilization. They explore how people in the West tend to focus on civilizational progress, which is technological and material advancement, while ignoring cultural progress.
The Difference Between Culture and Civilization
- Culture includes internal devices such as art and ritual, while civilization refers to material improvements.
- People in the West tend to only focus on civilizational progress, but culturally there has been a great consistency of progress throughout history.
- The idea that people are becoming better with improving material conditions of society is denounced as false.
Internal Reality and Material World
- The speaker disagrees with the author's argument that culture is always quintessentially religious and emerges from the innermost of human beings.
- He argues that there is no contradiction between the aggression of one's innermost reality and its application to the material world.
- Architecture can be seen as both an art form and an application of intelligence to the material world.
Religious Civilization
- Civilization does not have to be strictly materialistic or secular; it can also be religious.
- A religious civilization involves both construction (the application of intelligence to the material world) and a sense of purpose for God's glory.
The Relationship Between Culture, Civilization and Religion
In this section, the speakers discuss the relationship between culture, civilization, and religion. They explore how these concepts intersect and inform one another.
The Importance of Religious Identity
- Muslims all over the world have a strong sense of religious identity.
- Visiting mosques like the Blue Mosque in Turkey can inform one's sense of identity as a Muslim.
Progress and Being a Better Human Being
- There is a contradiction between progress and being a better human being.
- Blindly denigrating progress is dangerous because it may pre-empt the possibility of becoming a human being.
- Progress can result in better human beings if it is informed by a vision that ties us to God.
Civilizational and Cultural Efflorescence
- It is possible to have simultaneous civilizational and cultural efflorescence.
- Some interlocutors suggest that we are living in a time of progress where religion is outmoded. However, this view is not shared by everyone.
- Modern medicine is an example of progress that has improved people's lives.
Technology and Civilizational Advancement
- Improved means to an unimproved end can lead to problems if there isn't any vision informing progress.
- Mechanical progress uninformed by any vision can lead to exactly what he's saying.
What is the author encouraging us to do?
The speakers discuss what the author of a book they are reading is encouraging readers to do.
European Thinkers and Radical Separation
- The author may have overindulged in radical separation between culture and civilization.
- The book is still valuable and one of the speaker's favorites.
- The author engages with his intellectual milieu in an intelligible way, taking seriously their positions and presuppositions while also taking Islam seriously.
Value of the Book
The speakers discuss the value of the book they are reading.
Conversing with Intellectual Milieu
- The author's ability to converse with his intellectual milieu in an intelligible way is appreciated.
- Muslim scholars often dismiss everything besides Islam or only superficially engage with other ideas.
- The speaker would like to see more engagement with Islam from Muslim scholars.
Marxism as an Example
- The author can talk about Marxism without categorically dismissing it.
- He points out important insights of Marxism but also critically engages with what he thinks is wrong about it.
- This critical engagement was refreshing for one of the speakers personally.
Looking for Models
One speaker discusses how he found a model in the book that could be instructive for him.
Crafting a Language and Tone
- As a young Muslim convert who is also black and male in academia, one speaker looks for models that can help him craft a language, tone, and critical posture that will enable him to bring Islam into conversation with his own society.
- The book provides such a model by engaging seriously with ideas that define our context.
Conclusion
One speaker concludes by discussing how this book inspires critical thinking about our context.
Critical Thinking
- The book is a brave and courageous work that inspires critical thinking about our context.
- The book is the product of a conversation where people engaged seriously with ideas that define their context.
The Role of Tradition in Society
In this section, the speaker discusses the role of tradition in society and how it can be used to address contemporary challenges.
Tradition as a Response to Challenges
- The speaker poses the question of whether an American immutable or a Muslim right whole neighbor is needed in America.
- He explains that tradition provides safety, validation, and community. It is a trans-historical intellectual community that allows individuals to read the traditions of the past and try to instantiate them.
- The speaker argues that tradition is not a removal from the realities of society but rather a way to figure out how Islam can successfully be brought to bear on both challenges and opportunities.
Different Ways of Doing Tradition
- The speaker acknowledges that there are different ways of doing tradition but emphasizes that tradition should not be seen as something removed from contemporary reality.
- He distinguishes between tradition and traditionalism, with traditionalism being the tendency to take undue comfort in shirking one's responsibility to address contemporary reality on the ground.
Challenges of Addressing Contemporary Reality
- The speaker agrees that addressing contemporary reality is an enormous challenge intellectually, emotionally, and financially.
- He notes that not everyone may be ready or willing to enter into this kind of challenge because it can be daunting.
Conclusion of the Discussion
The speaker mentions that their time has expired and asks if the guest can say a word about what they have been working on. The guest declines.
Importance of Language in Islam
The speaker discusses the importance of language in Islam, citing the work of Bay Govich. He notes that many people may misunderstand Govich's use of language, but his aim is to take language away from dominant civilizations so it can acquire new meanings that better empower Islam to speak in its own voice. He emphasizes the need for Muslims to read Govich's book in its entirety to understand his arguments in context.
- Many people will critique or misunderstand Govich's point because he uses novel language.
- Govich aims to take language away from dominant civilizations so it can acquire new meanings that better empower Islam.
- It is important for Muslims to read Govich's book in its entirety to understand his arguments in context.
- Muslims cannot leave the language of religion, politics, economics, and sociology solely in the hands of non-Muslim West and expect to articulate themselves in the voice of Islam.
Contributions to Islam
The speaker argues that all Muslims have something to contribute to Islam and cites Sinan's architecture as an example. He notes that even children can appreciate the grandeur of Islamic architecture and suggests that it can impact their ability to sustain themselves as Muslims in society.
- All Muslims have something to contribute to Islam.
- Even children can appreciate Islamic architecture and it can impact their ability to sustain themselves as Muslims in society.
Understanding America in Conversation with Christian Tradition
In this section, the speaker discusses the importance of understanding America and placing Christian tradition in conversation with it. He mentions how Ranjo Neighbor was a theologian who focused on moving America towards a vision consistent with his Christian beliefs.
Ranjo Neighbor's Influence
- Ranjo Neighbor was a seminary trained theologian who had mastered Christian tradition.
- His primary focus was understanding America and placing that tradition in conversation with it.
- Presidents listened to him because he addressed issues in America that appeared to violate his Christian vision.
Importance of Muslim Tradition
- The average everyday Muslim is not more literate with regard to what Muslim tradition is.
- Due to this lack of familiarity, Muslims are unable to speak intelligently about Western topics or address issues that appear to violate their Islamic beliefs.
- Without filters or tools, Muslims tend towards wholesale rejection or acceptance of Western ideas.
Knowledge Needed for Addressing Issues
- The amount of Islamic knowledge needed for addressing Western topics depends on the specific issue being discussed.
- The process of trying to address an issue determines the level of knowledge required.
- Cultural issues may only require knowledge of culturally permissible parameters, while moving culture from one point to another requires more than just knowledge.
The Importance of Reading and Disagreeing with Books
In this section, the speaker discusses the importance of reading books even if we disagree with them. He also talks about how Muslim scholars bear the burden of understanding and analyzing books.
Importance of Reading Books We Disagree With
- Reading books we disagree with can enhance our understanding, effectiveness, and stature in society.
- Even if we disagree with a book, the disagreement can lead to meaningful insights.
Burden of Muslim Scholars
- Muslim scholars bear the burden of analyzing books.
- The book "100" was a great book to the speaker.
Announcements
This section contains announcements related to upcoming programs and campaigns.
Winter Program
- The winter program will take place at Adams Center in Virginia on MLK weekend (January 13th to 15th).
- Registration is open at allenprogram.com.
- Scholarships are available for students who want to attend.
Giving Tuesday Campaign
- Participants are invited to participate in the Giving Tuesday campaign to support summer and winter programs.
- Visit islandprogram.org for more information.
Summer Program
- Registration is open for the summer program which takes place from July 18th to July 30th at Benedictine University in Chicago, Illinois.
- The program covers several topics such as Hadith science and contemporary issues.
Turn any video into a summary like this
YouTube links, meetings, lectures. With transcripts, search, and chat.