The Rise & Fall of Arena Shooters

The Rise & Fall of Arena Shooters

The Rise and Fall of Arena Shooters

In this video, the speaker discusses the rise and fall of arena shooters in gaming. He explains what an arena shooter is, its characteristics, and how it evolved from arcade and space shooters. The speaker also talks about the decline of arena shooters' popularity and why they failed to appeal to a broader audience.

The Rise of Arena Shooters

  • FPS games are an evolution of arcade and space shooters.
  • Wolfenstein 3D is credited as being the first FPS title that people cared about.
  • Quake and Unreal Tournament are considered the first true arena shooters.
  • Arena shooters are characterized by ultra-fast movement, an arsenal of weapons, power-ups found on maps, no two weapon system, equal starts for both teams, and great soundtracks.

The Fall of Arena Shooters

  • Developers have tried to revitalize the genre with games like LawBreakers but have not been successful.
  • Doom 2016's multiplayer felt antiquated compared to modern FPS games.
  • There seems to be no mass-market appeal for these so-called "boomer shooters."
  • Cheap copies flooded the market in the early '90s leading to a decline in quality.

Why Did They Fail?

  • Studios didn't figure out how to make these games appeal to a broader audience.
  • Multiplayer-only games don't sell well anymore because players want more content for their money.
  • Modern gamers prefer slower-paced tactical gameplay over fast-paced action-packed gameplay.

The Emergence of FPS Games

This section discusses the emergence of first-person shooter (FPS) games and how they evolved over time. It covers the early days of Doom, network multiplayer, LAN parties, and co-op gameplay.

Doom: The Revolutionary Game

  • Doom was a revolutionary game that blew everyone's minds in 1993.
  • It introduced a new deathmatch mode and started the trend of network multiplayer and LAN parties.
  • Doom launched its official online multiplayer component a year later, offering co-op gameplay.

Competitors to Doom

  • Duke Nukem 3D was the first successful Doom clone that added elements of comedy and satire to the genre.
  • Dark Forces introduced looking up and down but had no multiplayer.
  • Quake fundamentally changed online FPS games by making it easier to find matches and introducing fully rendered 3D graphics. It also popularized speedrunning and esports.

Impact on Gaming Industry

  • Star Wars Dark Forces drew a whole new crowd to arena shooters with its rabid wide audience.
  • Arena shooters would only get better from here on out as competition spurred innovation.

The Rise of Console FPS Games

This section discusses how console and PC gaming were two separate markets with no overlap. Console FPS titles were never considered a legitimate threat until GoldenEye was released, which changed the stigma that FPS titles couldn't work on consoles.

The Impact of GoldenEye

  • Console and PC gaming were two separate markets with almost no overlap.
  • GoldenEye brought FPS games to consoles.
  • Arena shooters were too fast and chaotic to be played on controllers, making them unpopular on consoles.
  • GoldenEye slowed down movement and forced players to make methodical decisions in combat, changing the stigma that FPS titles couldn't work on consoles.

Other Attempts at Bringing Shooters to Consoles

  • Doom 64 established a presence for shooters outside of the PC market.
  • Unreal sold 1.5 million copies by 2002, but other sub-genres like Metal Gear Solid, Rainbow Six, Star Siege Tribes started to pop up as well.
  • Gamers began experiencing different types of shooters beyond arena shooters.

Half-Life's Evolution of Single Player FPS Games

This section discusses how Half-Life evolved single-player side of FPS while also putting its own spin on the arena shooter format. It emphasizes the importance of world-building, storytelling, atmosphere, and cut scenes in single-player games.

Half-Life's Impact on Single Player FPS Games

  • Prior to Half-Life, Arena Shooters had competent fun single players.
  • Half-Life emphasized world-building, storytelling, atmosphere and cut scenes in single-player games.
  • If games like Quake and Unreal had emphasized their single player the way Doom did, they might still be relevant today.

The Rise of Hero Shooters

This section discusses how Team Fortress Classic and Counter-Strike changed the FPS genre. It emphasizes the introduction of classes and heroes in preset loadouts as opposed to even starts and everything being on the map.

Team Fortress Classic

  • Team Fortress Classic was a mod for Quake that introduced the idea of classes and heroes in preset loadouts.
  • Valve hired the creators of the mod to work on it as a full-fledged title.

Counter-Strike

  • Counter-Strike took the best aspects of Rainbow Six and Half-Life and threw them in a blender.
  • Its popularity was so unprecedented that it was actually surpassing the games it was emulating.

The Rise of Arena Shooters

This section discusses the rise of arena shooters and how they were able to find a home on new platforms.

The Success of Unreal Tournament

  • Unreal Tournament was a highly modular game that put the same tools the developers used to make it in the hands of the player base.
  • While most shooters around this era were either set in the future or more modern times, Unreal Tournament took us back to arena-style gameplay.
  • GoldenEye, Perfect Dark, Half-Life, Team Fortress, Counter-Strike and Medal of Honor all introduced a new spin on this genre.

Changes for Console Games

  • Console shooters were on the rise and Arena shooters from PC were able to find a home on these new platforms.
  • Games like Time Splitters and Perfect Dark showed that movement and gameplay changes could be made that were less chaotic and accessible to controller games.

Halo Combat Evolved

This section discusses how Halo Combat Evolved changed FPS games by appealing to both casual and hardcore gamers.

Designing for Casual Gamers

  • Halo was designed as a party shooter game that offered casual four-player fun in a much more mature sci-fi setting.
  • Some debate has been had over whether Halo is an arena shooter or not but it shared many of the same principles such as Deathmatch equals Slayer right all weapons and power-ups are found on the map.

Success Across Platforms

  • Combat Evolved marked a big shift in the strategy of selling FPS games as console was where the money truly was.
  • Like Half-Life, Halo excelled in both its single player and multiplayer offerings spawning a multimedia franchise worth billions with a story that captured the hearts and minds of millions of Gamers.

The Fall of Arena Shooters

This section discusses how the success of games like Halo 2 and Call of Duty contributed to the fall of arena shooters.

Changes in Online Gaming

  • Xbox Live made online gaming far easier and accessible without the need for an elaborate setup.
  • Arena shooters had been growing stubborn and stagnant. It had been 11 years since Doom released, and aside from many visual upgrades, there hadn't been much that changed.

Conclusion

  • After this generation of consoles, it would be a long time before another arena shooter game would be played again.
  • Developers were no longer trying to dethrone Doom or compete with Arena Shooters; they were trying to compete with Halo.

The Decline of Arena Shooters

This section discusses the decline of arena shooters and how they lost relevance in the gaming industry.

FPS Titles Shifted Away from Arena Shooters

  • FPS titles shifted away from arena shooters towards more story-driven action horror games.
  • Modern military and World War II shooters took over, leaving arena shooters behind.
  • FPS titles became more user-friendly with slower movement, regenerating health, and a two-weapon inventory.

Rise of Cooperative Shooters

  • Cooperative shooters like Left 4 Dead, Destiny, and Borderlands started to become popular.
  • FPS titles became more social and team-oriented with vehicles, trash talk in lobbies, squads, teamwork, and coordination.

Old School Mode

  • Call of Duty 4 had an "Old School" playlist that was abandoned due to low player counts.

Reasons for Decline

  • Arena shooters were too complex for casual players to enjoy without becoming hardcore players themselves.
  • There were too many different subgenres of shooter to compete with nowadays.
  • Gamers wanted something more than bunny hopping around.

Why Arena Shooters Died

This section discusses why Arena Shooters died and how companies like software and valve were unable to revive them.

Companies Like Software and Valve

  • Software and Valve sat in similar positions after the success of Doom 3 and Half-Life 2.
  • They had too much dignity to milk their franchises and create anything less than a stellar revolutionary new entry.
  • Both franchises went dormant for years.

Epic Games

  • Epic games was developing a new Arena shooter back in 2014 but completely switched Focus to work on this upcoming third person shooter.
  • How long would epic games have been in business if they hadn't abandoned Unreal Tournament for Fortnite?

Franchises and Studios

  • Duke Nukem Forever had no direction whatsoever that was just a pure disaster, Quake 3 was a big hit but it took like nine years for a sequel to come out.
  • By that point Halo 2 and Xbox Live were blasting off into space.
  • The next Half-Life game would be a VR title released 500 million years after Half-Life 2.
  • Bethesda and ID software did revive Doom but as an experience of being an ultra badass blasting demons.
  • With its sequel Eternal they ditched the entire concept of Arena multiplayer entirely in favor of making this one mode that I played three times and never touched again.

Revitalizing the Genre

  • The best way of bringing back Arena Shooters was through fun easy-to-understand movement Tech like grappling hooks.
  • This feature has been universally praised and beloved in Doom Eternal, Halo Infinite, and Titanfall 2.
  • Arena Shooters simply didn't adapt in a way that could attract a new audience so they were left with their dwindling old Boomers.
  • Developers realized that the Casual audience shouldn't be neglected they introduced a lot of elements of Randomness.

Gatekeeping

  • Quakers want you to follow Jank written guides on how to perform basic movement because things like bunny hopping and Rocket jumping aren't explained in the games and never had intuitive Control Systems implemented that made those actions easier.
  • Shooting at a blur darting across a CRT monitor with a ball Mouse while compensating for 200 millisecond lag isn't very engaging for hours either.
  • By the time technology caught up with the genre paste in gatekeeping happened.

The Fall of Arena Shooters

This section discusses the decline of arena shooters and how attempts to revive the genre failed to gain significant audiences.

Attempts at Reviving the Genre

  • Reviving this genre hardly made a splash.
  • Games felt outdated and primitive, even Doom 2016 looked like it was from the early 2000s.
  • Each new release that failed to Garner a significant audience only made it harder for the next one to try.
  • At a certain point, they just stopped trying.

The Legacy of Arena Shooters

This section talks about how despite their fall in popularity, arena shooters still have dedicated player bases and are playable today.

Indie Games and Dedicated Player Bases

  • Some indie games perform moderately well.
  • A lot of these Arena Shooters are still playable with very small but dedicated player bases.
  • You could still play the original Half-Life's multiplayer if you really want to. It's actually quite fun.

Quake Champions and Interest in Arena Shooters Today

This section discusses how interest in arena shooters has never been lower, even with recent releases like Quake Champions.

Quake Champions' Struggle for Mainstream Success

  • Even Quake Champions seems unable to break into the mainstream.
  • Interest in this genre has never been lower.

The Slow Death of Arena Shooters

This section explains how the decline of arena shooters was a slow process due to stubborn pride and changing trends.

Stubborn Pride and Changing Trends

  • The decline of arena shooters was not instant but slow.
  • It's a case of stubborn pride and a change in trends.

Hope for the Future?

This section discusses whether there is hope for arena shooters to make a comeback.

Doom Eternal and the Possibility of Revival

  • Whatever chance there might have been for arena shooters to make a comeback most likely died with Doom Eternal.
  • If anyone can bring back the intense fast-paced action of Arena Shooters and revive the genre, it's gonna be Doom.

Conclusion

This section concludes the video by thanking viewers and asking for their thoughts on arena shooters.

Final Thoughts

  • Interest in this genre has never been lower.
  • Leave a like if you enjoyed the video, subscribe to The Act Man for more awesome content.
  • Let me know your thoughts and opinions in the comments below.

Turn any video into a summary like this

YouTube links, meetings, lectures. With transcripts, search, and chat.

Video description

At one point the Arena Shooter genre was king of all FPS games. From Doom to Duke Nukem, Quake and Unreal Tournament, the genre has a long history of successful and beloved IP's. But in the last 15 years or so, it seems this genre of FPS has fallen completely out of relevance. Why? Why did Arena Shooters rise and fall? Follow me on Twitch ➤ https://www.twitch.tv/theactingmale SUPPORT the Channel ► https://www.patreon.com/TheActMan ____TIME STAMPS____ Introduction – 0:00 What Is an Arena Shooter? – 1:27 The Rise of Arena Shooters (Wolfenstein, Doom & Quake) – 4:55 The Dawn of Console FPS – 11:14 Valve Enters the Frey – 14:27 Combat Evolved – 18:07 The Dawn of Online Gaming – 20:30 End of an Era – 22:38 Conclusion – 31:18 Editing Help ➤ https://www.youtube.com/@UCj-9icIF3_RswXJy1O6cD-A Thumbnail ➤ https://twitter.com/EtherealEOD How Much Does Multiplayer Population Matter? (Raycevick) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DlCpX53pvac&t ✪ CONNECT WITH ME ✪ Subscribe ↪ https://www.youtube.com/c/TheActMan?sub_confirmation=1 Twitch ➤ https://www.twitch.tv/theactingmale Twitter ➤ https://twitter.com/TheActMan_YT Act Man TV ➤ http://bit.ly/2kPXk7f Discord ➤ https://discord.gg/yBABtkh Instagram ➤ https://www.instagram.com/theactman_yt/ Xbox Live Gamertag ➤ The Act Man