Judges weigh several factors in OWI sentencing

Drunk Driving Sentencing in Wisconsin: A Judicial Perspective

Overview of Drunk Driving Cases

• The mission of Projects Drive Sober aims to reduce drunk driving incidents in Wisconsin, highlighting the tragic losses associated with such offenses.

• Judge William Atkinson discusses his 34 years of experience handling drunk driving cases, emphasizing that while there are sentencing standards, judges have discretion based on individual circumstances.

Notable Cases Reviewed

Case 1: Savannah Dumas

• On April 19, 2017, Savannah Dumas crashed her car, resulting in the death of her friend Megan Frays and injuries to another passenger.

• Dumas had a breathalyzer reading of 0.12% and received a sentence of three months in jail along with ten years probation after pleading no contest to homicide by intoxicated use of a vehicle.

• Judge Atkinson noted Dumas's youth as a factor for leniency, stressing the importance of educating young people about alcohol dangers.

Case 2: David Meyer

• In contrast, on August 17, 2017, David Meyer hit and killed two pedestrians while having a breathalyzer reading of 0.21%.

• Meyer had prior OWI offenses and was sentenced to ten years in prison for his actions; this reflects the significant difference in sentencing based on case specifics.

Key Insights from Sentencing Decisions

• Judge Atkinson highlighted that each case is unique; he believes Dumas can share her story to influence peers positively regarding drunk driving.

• He advocates for societal change towards reducing drunk driving incidents through education and cultural shifts rather than solely punitive measures.