15 Best Mechanical Pencils Reviewed, Rotring, Pentel, Ohto, Graphgear, Staedtler

Name: 15 Best Mechanical Pencils Reviewed, Rotring, Pentel, Ohto, Graphgear, Staedtler
Uploaded: 2020-01-17T17:22:57.000Z
Duration: 2 h 22 min 7 s

Mechanical Pencil Review: Insights and Recommendations

Introduction to the Review

The speaker introduces a review of 15 mechanical pencils, sharing personal opinions on their pros and cons.

Emphasizes that the review is based on extensive use for drawing rather than writing, setting the context for the evaluation.

Purpose of Mechanical Pencils

Clarifies that this review focuses on mechanical pencils suitable for drawing, while acknowledging some comments from previous videos regarding writing.

Mentions that lead type affects performance more than the pencil itself, indicating a preference for specific brands.

Lead Preferences

The speaker has used pencil leads from a brand called "Pencil Hi Polymer" for 30 years, highlighting their quality in terms of darkness and smoothness.

Discusses two varieties of leads: old-style and newer brake-resistant versions, both preferred by the speaker.

Differences Between Drawing and Writing Pencils

Explains that while there are similarities between writing and drawing with mechanical pencils, grip size plays a crucial role in usability.

Compares grip sizes between different models; larger grips are better suited for drawing as they allow more control during expressive movements.

Grip Importance in Drawing

Highlights how holding a pencil further back can enhance movement and flow when drawing compared to writing positions.

Notes that comfort is essential when using pencils for extended periods, especially during detailed work or shading techniques.

Mechanical Pencil Features and Comfort

Importance of Comfort in Mechanical Pencils

The primary criterion for selecting a mechanical pencil is comfort, regardless of its features or price.

Users should assess how the pencil feels in hand, including any sharp edges or uncomfortable areas that may affect usability.

Overview of Mechanical Pencil Features

For beginners considering their first mechanical pencil for artwork, understanding key features is essential.

Despite being a high-quality pencil with numerous features, the speaker finds one specific model uncomfortable for drawing.

Specific Model Discussion: Oso Super Pro Mecha

The Oso Super Pro Mecha is highlighted as a notable model featuring 0.5mm lead diameter.

Common lead sizes include 0.2mm, 0.3mm, 0.5mm, 0.7mm, and 0.9mm; however, the speaker prefers using 0.5mm due to its variety of available leads.

Key Features to Consider

A comfortable grip section is crucial; it should provide enough friction without sliding during use.

The length and design of the grip can significantly impact user experience.

Unique Features of the Oso Super Pro Mecha

This model includes a removable top for easy access to an eraser and has an LED indicator for lead hardness.

The end cap allows users to adjust and lock the position of lead indicators securely.

Additional Functionalities

A unique feature includes a pin designed to unblock lead if it gets stuck within the sleeve.

The pocket clip can be unscrewed for those who find it uncomfortable while using the pencil.

Mechanism Quality

The retractable mechanism ensures that the lead sleeve remains protected when not in use.

Mechanical Pencil Review: Features and Comfort

Overview of Features

The mechanical pencil features a retractable sleeve that is described as "rock-solid" and meets all necessary requirements for functionality.

It allows for adjustable lead increments, enabling users to click out varying amounts of lead (e.g., 1mm or 0.5mm), although the speaker finds this feature unnecessary for general use.

For drafting purposes, precise lead adjustments may be beneficial, but casual users may not find it essential.

Comparison of Pencils

The speaker transitions to discussing other mechanical pencils, particularly the Rotring models, which have received high praise from others in the community.

After purchasing both the Rotring 600 and Rapid Pro models, expectations were set high due to their reputation as top-tier mechanical pencils.

Quality vs. Comfort

The Rotring products are noted for their build quality; however, comfort issues arise with certain designs that affect usability during extended drawing sessions.

An LED indicator on some models is highlighted as a useful feature for identifying different hardnesses of lead when using multiple pencils.

Ergonomics and Usability

While the build quality is praised (solid brass construction), ergonomic design flaws can hinder comfort during prolonged use.

The hexagonal shape transitioning into a cylindrical grip creates sharp corners that can be uncomfortable when held for long periods.

Final Thoughts on Drawing Experience

Despite its aesthetic appeal and durability ("bomb-proof"), if a pencil isn't comfortable, it fails its primary purpose for artists who draw extensively.

Pencil Comparison: Rotary 600 vs. Rotary 500

Design and Comfort

The hexagonal shape of the Rotary 600 is compared to a bolt, making it uncomfortable to hold, while the rounded design of another pencil offers a better grip.

The "red ring" on the pencils signifies quality; it transitions smoothly between the grip section and body, enhancing comfort during use.

Although the grip is excellent, the absence of an LED indicator is noted as a drawback for the Rotary 600.

Weight and Size Considerations

The speaker prefers a wider, heavier pencil style but suggests that a .5mm clutch pencil might be more suitable for their needs.

The retractable sleeve feature allows for easy storage without damaging the pencil; however, some wobble in the tip is present but not distracting during drawing.

Price vs. Quality

Despite being pricier, the Rotary 600 offers good value if one does not require an LED indicator; it includes an eraser and feels comfortable in hand.

Rotary 500: A Budget-Friendly Alternative

Similarities with Rotary 600

The Rotary 500 resembles the 600 but features a plastic body instead of metal; it has a non-replaceable grip section which limits customization options.

Ergonomics and User Experience

Users find that despite its lower price point, the ergonomics are improved due to more rounded corners where it meets the grip section.

Preference for weight distribution leads some users to favor lighter pencils like the Rotary 500 over heavier models.

Personal Preference Insights

Comfort plays a significant role in choosing between models; despite lacking premium materials, many prefer using lighter models like the Rotary 500 for extended periods.

The Evolution of Rotary Pencils

Historical Context

Discussion about older versions of rotary pencils reveals they were more streamlined and felt better in hand compared to newer designs.

Collectibility and Value

Mechanical Pencil Review and Insights

Overview of Pencils Discussed

The latest version of a standard pocket clip mechanical pencil features a siliconized rubber grip, which is comfortable but chunky. It's affordable yet lacks advanced features.

The reviewer reflects on their experience with the Rotring 600 mechanical pencil, indicating dissatisfaction that led to exploring alternatives.

A new pencil, described as "wispy precision," offers a comfortable writing experience and surpasses the Rotring 600 in comfort.

Design and Functionality

The new pencil has a design similar to the Rotring 600 but lacks an LED indicator. It features a full metal jacket and an adequate grip.

Available in retractable and fixed sleeve styles, the reviewer chose the retractable option for convenience but noted significant wobbling issues.

Performance Issues

The retractable version suffers from excessive wobble, making it feel cheap and unreliable for daily use.

Due to its instability, the reviewer regrets not opting for the fixed sleeve version instead of the retractable one.

Recommendations

For those interested in this model, it's advised to choose the fixed sleeve variant over the retractable due to performance concerns regarding wobbling.

Despite its flaws, the packaging includes spare erasers and leads, which adds value; however, quality control may vary across units.

Additional Features

The mechanical pencil comes with large spare erasers that are unusual compared to typical offerings in this category.

Spare leads included are high-quality; however, specific details about them remain unclear from packaging descriptions.

Pricing Considerations

Prices for these pencils range around £15–£20 depending on retailer and time of purchase; they are positioned as higher-end options worth considering based on performance reviews.

Popular Alternatives

The Uni Kuru Toga is highlighted as a popular choice among users due to its unique rotating mechanism that maintains lead sharpness during use.

This mechanism allows consistent line width by rotating lead each time pressure is applied while writing or drawing.

Mechanical Pencil Review and Insights

Preferences for Drawing Tools

The speaker expresses a preference for traditional mechanical pencils over the reviewed pencil, citing issues with lead rotation affecting shading techniques.

They describe their method of achieving varying line widths by using different edges of the lead, which is not possible with the reviewed pencil due to its design.

The speaker critiques the reviewed pencil's mechanism that wears down lead evenly, limiting artistic flexibility in drawing.

Suitability for Different Uses

While acknowledging some positive feedback about the pencil, they conclude it is unsuitable for drawing except in specific scenarios like architectural work or fine details.

The mechanism only functions effectively when pressure is applied consistently; thus, it fails during varied drawing techniques.

Writing vs. Drawing Performance

Despite its shortcomings in drawing, the speaker finds the pencil excellent for writing due to its consistent line width and comfort.

They note that while the grip section could be improved for drawing purposes, it works well for writing as users hold it lower towards the tip.

Design Flaws and Limitations

Criticism is directed at the lack of a lead indicator and an inadequately small eraser that diminishes usability.

Comfort-wise, they find no faults with how it feels in hand but emphasize its limitations in artistic applications.

Comparison with Other Pencils

The speaker introduces another model (Uni Shift), initially impressed by its grip but ultimately disappointed by design flaws such as a wobbly lead mechanism.

They highlight issues with this model’s small eraser and lack of a lead indicator as significant drawbacks.

Praise for High Quality Alternatives

Transitioning to discussing their favorite model (Graph Gear 1000), they express strong approval based on quality and feel compared to other models discussed earlier.

Mechanical Pencil Review: The Best Choice?

Overview of the Mechanical Pencil Experience

The speaker has extensively used a specific mechanical pencil for over two and a half to three years, highlighting its durability and comfort as key features.

This pencil is described as the most comfortable mechanical pencil ever used, particularly beneficial for artists who frequently adjust their grip while drawing.

The grip section is noted for its perfect balance between being cushioned and not overly grippy, allowing for smooth handling without discomfort.

Unique Features of the Pencil

A standout feature is the pocket clip that retracts into the body when pressed, ensuring it remains pocket-safe without hindering usability during drawing.

The design includes an LED indicator that adjusts seamlessly with the grip section, preventing any awkwardness or hard edges while in use.

Performance Insights

Users are advised on how to properly adjust the LED indicator by holding the grip section while turning; improper handling can lead to damage.

Feedback from other users confirms satisfaction with this pencil, reinforcing its reputation as potentially the best mechanical pencil available.

Durability and Long-term Use

Despite heavy usage over three years, there are no visible scratches or dents on the pencil, showcasing its robust construction.

Some wear is noted at the tip after extensive use; however, it does not affect performance during drawing sessions.

Comparison with Other Pencils

The speaker expresses a strong preference for this mechanical pencil over more expensive alternatives like the Rotring 600 series, emphasizing personal satisfaction over brand prestige.

Mechanical Pencil Comparisons and Insights

Long-Distance Draw Frame vs. Rotring 600

The long-distance draw frame is praised for its comfort, claiming it outperforms other options regardless of price or hype.

The speaker expresses skepticism about the Rotring 600, describing it as a solid pencil but overhyped compared to similarly built alternatives that are more comfortable and less expensive.

Quality and Value of Pencils

The speaker believes many reviews of the Rotring 600 are honest, highlighting its Japanese craftsmanship and good quality.

Initially priced around £20, the pencil can now be found for as low as $6.99 to £15, offering great value for money.

Features of the Pencil P200 Range

The speaker showcases several P200 pencils in different lead grades, emphasizing their classic design and functionality.

A preference for LED indicators on these pencils is mentioned due to their affordability and versatility in using various leads.

Drawing Experience with P200 Pencils

Holding a P200 pencil provides a sense of precision akin to being a "graphite Jedi," allowing for accurate detail work.

In contrast, heavier metal-bodied pencils do not offer the same lightness or precision feel when drawing.

Durability and Comfort Over Time

The speaker has used their current black P205 pencil for nearly 20 years without significant wear, demonstrating durability despite being plastic.

Emphasizing comfort, the lightweight nature of the P200 series makes them preferable over heavier models like the Rotring 600.

Personal Recommendations

Strongly recommends trying out the Pencil P200 range despite lacking certain features like an LED indicator; they are highly regarded among artists.

Mechanical Pencil Review: Unique Features and Recommendations

Overview of Pencil Preferences

The speaker expresses a personal preference against using certain pencils for extended periods, emphasizing that while they are great, they recommend a good everyday pencil instead.

Introduction to Pencil Arends

The speaker introduces two models of the Pencil Arends, noting their differences and similarities to the P200 range. They highlight the comfort and balance of these pencils.

Unique Mechanism of Pencil Arends

A unique feature of the Pencil Arends is discussed: it uses a mechanism that allows for ultra-fine lead without breaking it easily.

The speaker explains how traditional fine leads break easily when used in standard pencils, which is why this specific design was created.

Lead Retraction Mechanism

The retractable tip mechanism is explained; clicking once extends the lead while clicking twice can break it.

Demonstration shows how little lead protrudes from the tip after one click, minimizing breakage risk.

Lead Wear Management

As lead wears down, the sleeve retracts automatically based on pressure applied to paper, reducing the need for constant clicking.

This innovative design allows users to maintain consistent line quality without frequent adjustments.

Applications in Art Techniques

The speaker discusses using these pencils for detailed work in watercolor line drawings due to their ability to dig into rough surfaces effectively.

Emphasizes their utility not just for regular drawing but also for techniques like pencil and wash where precision is crucial.

Recommendations for Artists

Concludes that anyone interested in fine detail should consider owning at least one model from the Pencil Arends series.

Lead Types and Recommendations

Mechanical Pencils Overview

Adjusting Drawing Techniques

When using mechanical pencils on drawing paper, it's important to adjust your drawing style. Pressing too hard can damage the paper, as harder leads may cut or tear it.

Preferred Pencil Hardness

The speaker prefers HB and B leads for their balance of usability and comfort, finding no need for additional degrees of hardness in pencils.

Graph Gear 500 Features

The Graph Gear 500 is highlighted as a favorite pencil. It includes a removable pocket clip and an LED indicator, with interchangeable erasers that are easy to replace.

Comparison with Other Brands

The Graph Gear 500 has a plastic body similar to the Rotring 500 but features a wider grip section for enhanced comfort. The design minimizes sharp corners where different materials meet.

Personal Preference for Comfort

While the speaker appreciates Rotring products, they express a preference for the Graph Gear series due to its comfort and quality at an affordable price point. They emphasize that this pencil feels better in hand compared to others.

Durability and Longevity of Mechanical Pencils

Long-lasting Performance

The speaker notes that the Graph Gear 500 has proven durable over years of use without any damage or wear, making it reliable for heavy usage.

Revisiting Other Models

Acknowledging previous discussions about other models like the Graph Gear 1000, the speaker reflects on their underutilization despite recognizing its comfort and quality features.

Key Features of Alternative Models

Another model discussed is the Steadler 925 series which offers basic features including an LED indicator but lacks some advanced options like a larger grip section found in other models.

Final Thoughts on Mechanical Pencils

Unique Offerings from Different Brands

An oddball pencil resembling the P200 range is mentioned; it’s made in Japan and impresses with its build quality despite being less known.

Mechanical Pencil Review and Insights

Overview of the Platinum Model

The reviewed pencil is a platinum model, specifically noted for being cheaper than the P200 range while maintaining a similar body shape.

It features an LED indicator but lacks advanced features like a retractable sleeve, making it a basic yet affordable option.

Design and Usability

The plastic design appears cheap with visible swirls, which may detract from its aesthetic appeal.

The grip is considered subpar compared to other models; it feels slippery and less comfortable during use.

Value for Money

Despite some drawbacks, the pencil remains usable and is priced around $1.99, making it accessible for those on a budget.

The reviewer emphasizes that this pencil is suitable for individuals who cannot afford more expensive options.

Selection Criteria for Pencils

A variety of mechanical pencils were reviewed to help viewers choose based on current market availability rather than vintage options.

Suggestions are welcomed in the comments for specific reviews on other mechanical pencils not covered in this video.

Drawing vs. Writing Focus

The review primarily targets selecting pencils suited for drawing rather than general writing tasks.

Links to affiliate products will be provided in the description to assist viewers in finding these pencils online.

Final Thoughts on Pencil Performance

While many pencils are available, the P200 range stands out as comfortable and precise despite being featureless.