Paxos CEO on Crypto Today & Why Stablecoins Are Exploding | Charles Cascarilla

Paxos CEO on Crypto Today & Why Stablecoins Are Exploding | Charles Cascarilla

What is the Enormous Opportunity in Financial Systems?

  • The total addressable market (TAM) for financial systems is vast, with $900 trillion in assets.
  • Current economic conditions reflect a K-shaped recovery, influenced by money printing and crypto market downturns.
  • The podcast serves informational purposes only; opinions expressed are not financial advice.

Insights from Charles Cascarilla

  • Charles Cascarilla, CEO of Paxos, returns to discuss his experiences since 2022.
  • His previous podcast appearance was influential for the hosts when starting Blockworks.
  • The crossover between traditional finance and crypto made his insights more accessible.

Reflections on Building Paxos

  • Recognizing Bitcoin and blockchain's potential was crucial for Paxos' foundation.
  • Initial thoughts included using blockchain as a universal ledger before Ethereum's rise.
  • Timing was a significant factor; institutions took longer than expected to adopt crypto.

Background and Evolution of Paxos

  • Charles co-founded Paxos after working in asset management during the financial crisis.
  • He previously managed investments across public and private companies through Liberty City Ventures.
  • Transitioning from investor to running a company provided valuable insights into business operations.

Lessons Learned from Running a Business

  • Being an operator has enhanced his investment perspective significantly.
  • Understanding disruption requires experience within the operational aspects of businesses.

Understanding Blockchain's Impact on Finance

Early Involvement in Blockchain

  • The speaker discusses the potential of blockchain to transform the financial system, similar to Bitcoin.
  • They reflect on their early involvement in the crypto space, noting how accessible information was back in 2010.
  • Attended the first Consensus event, highlighting a mix of Comic-Con attendees and Bitcoin enthusiasts.

Longevity in Crypto Business

  • The speaker attributes their company's longevity to a strong mission and vision amidst competition.
  • They emphasize that many founders have burned out, but they remain driven by Paxos' goals.
  • Their aim is to democratize finance and enable trustworthy asset movement.

Navigating Market Cycles

  • Discusses the rapid shifts within the crypto market and various cycles since 2010.
  • Highlights challenges faced while trying to integrate traditional assets onto blockchain technology.
  • Reflects on unexpected growth over 14 years, including reaching significant asset milestones.

Evolution of Crypto Assets

  • Notes debates about blockchain's relationship with crypto from as early as 2013.
  • Observes that Bitcoin remains a reliable source of truth despite numerous tokens emerging over time.
  • Expresses surprise at the proliferation of tokens compared to public companies.

Institutional Infrastructure Challenges

  • Mentions that institutional players did not initially cater to retail access for crypto assets.
  • Points out that major businesses focused on retail access rather than replatforming traditional assets onto blockchain.

Industry Dynamics and Token Market

  • Discussion on the current state of the token market with over 40,000 tokens available.
  • Speaker reflects on attending Token 249 in Singapore, feeling out of touch with the industry.
  • Observations about high spending at events and a sense of market saturation.

Market Speculation and Corrections

  • Acknowledgment of significant corrections in crypto tokens since the event.
  • Caution about the ease of creating tokens leading to potential failures for most projects.
  • Comparison of token creation to website creation, emphasizing that most are likely worthless.

Value Chain Insights

  • American Express's profitability compared to airlines highlights value chain disparities.
  • Easier to build businesses around trading crypto than launching new tokens.

Bitcoin vs. Other Cryptos

  • Distinction between crypto as an incentive mechanism and Bitcoin as a store of value.
  • Importance of network effects in community-driven projects using crypto.

Mathematical Proof and Trust Issues

  • Bitcoin viewed as mathematical proof competing with gold's geological proof.
  • Concerns about Bitcoin's longevity due to evolving cryptographic algorithms.

Fiat Currency and Debt Dynamics

  • Fiat currency seen as future proof of work tied to debt expectations.
  • Risks associated with excessive debt issuance potentially leading to fiat currency destruction.

Bitcoin's Value and Market Dynamics

Price Decline and Future Outlook

  • Original price of Bitcoin was $19; now around $4,500, indicating a significant decline in dollar value.
  • Bitcoin is positioned well as a store of value despite current volatility compared to gold.
  • Different dynamics exist between Bitcoin and gold; Bitcoin still seen as a speculative asset.

Volatility and Market Perception

  • Transition from speculative asset to store of value involves overcoming volatility.
  • Importance of upgrading mathematical proofs for long-term confidence in Bitcoin's value.
  • Historical perspective: Gold has been valued for thousands of years, while Bitcoin is relatively new.

Central Banks and Market Trends

  • Current market conditions show uncertainty; narratives often arise post-decline without clear reasons.
  • Central banks buying gold creates momentum; retail interest follows suit when prices rise.
  • Liquidity in fiat money leads to unpredictable market behaviors, similar to historical trends.

Future Catalysts for Growth

  • Anticipation of a significant event that could unlock institutional investment in Bitcoin again.
  • Past events like Coinbase's IPO have historically influenced market sentiment positively.
  • Four-year cycles may play a role in predicting future price movements.

Supply Dynamics and Market Behavior

  • Changes in supply impact price action significantly; ETFs have introduced new dynamics to the market.
  • Large amounts of capital can shift markets dramatically, emphasizing absolute dollars over percentages.

Market Dynamics and Psychological Factors in Trading

Selling Trends Among Long-Term Holders

  • Many long-term holders have made significant profits, leading to increased selling activity as they reassess their positions.
  • A psychological threshold at $100K influenced selling behavior among early adopters who became disillusioned with the industry.
  • Some original investors prioritize diversifying their interests rather than holding onto Bitcoin indefinitely.

Current Market Conditions

  • The broader market is challenging to predict, with volatility being a key characteristic of current conditions.
  • Political actions can create market fluctuations, complicating the ability to forecast trends accurately.
  • Ongoing geopolitical tensions may impact negotiation dynamics and market stability.

Supply Chain Disruptions and Inflation Pressures

  • Supply chain issues are causing inflationary pressures across various sectors, not just oil.
  • Significant capital expenditures in AI could lead to both inflationary and deflationary effects on the economy.
  • Rising costs for data center infrastructure raise concerns about future returns on investment.

Interest Rates and Economic Equilibrium

  • Higher interest rates may be necessary due to increased capital spending, impacting future economic balance.
  • Historical context suggests that failing to raise rates during previous booms led to ongoing financial instability.
  • Current debt levels complicate decisions regarding interest rate adjustments amidst economic uncertainty.

Bitcoin as an Alternative Asset

  • Bitcoin is viewed as a potential solution to current economic challenges, providing an alternative pricing mechanism amid dollar volatility.

Economic Insights on Dollar Value and Asset Allocation

Understanding the Dollar's Decline

  • The dollar's decline is more significant than asset appreciation; historical context of gold's value as a month's salary or a suit.
  • Gold represents a unit of energy, linking its value to tangible goods and services.
  • Market predictions are challenging; alternative asset valuations like Bitcoin and gold provide different perspectives.

Investment Strategies in Current Markets

  • Investors face choices: allocate funds to Bitcoin, gold, or equities like Nvidia and Amazon.
  • Evaluating assets based on potential returns against dollar depreciation is crucial for investment decisions.
  • Risk-adjusted returns show that traditional assets may not perform well compared to gold or Bitcoin.

Societal Impacts of Monetary Policy

  • Global M2 growth at 10% annually necessitates equivalent returns just to maintain purchasing power.
  • Wealth disparity arises from asset ownership versus stagnant real wages; this reflects the K-shaped recovery phenomenon.
  • Government spending exceeds tax revenue, leading to economic challenges without easy solutions.

Addressing Economic Challenges

  • The U.S. faces a spending problem rather than a tax issue; reducing government expenditure could trigger recessionary effects.
  • Political reluctance prevents necessary fiscal adjustments, perpetuating reliance on money printing.
  • A shift towards long-term solutions like Bitcoin is essential for creating a sustainable financial system.

Future Financial Systems

  • A new financial framework based on proof of work can address current economic issues effectively.
  • Collective responsibility in voting for policies contributes to ongoing economic challenges; no one favors austerity measures.

Discussion on Economic Policies and Blockchain

Economic Perspectives

  • Discussion on voting for a "mini depression" as a potential economic strategy.
  • Emphasis on driving energy costs down to create deflationary growth, which could support debt.
  • Mention of ZKSync as a secure platform for institutions needing privacy and compliance.

Blockworks Investor Relations

  • Introduction of Blockworks investor relations aimed at improving transparency in the crypto market.
  • Highlighting the need for a credible story for investors in an on-chain business environment.
  • Description of Blockworks IR as a platform combining analytics, portals, and advisory support.

Insights on Paxos

  • Inquiry into why Paxos is focused on solving problems identified during the 2008 financial crisis.
  • Reflection on past attempts to create private chains and the shift towards public chains.
  • Discussion about the debate between private vs. public chains and their implications.

Infrastructure Focus

  • Clarification that Paxos aims to provide infrastructure rather than build retail offerings like exchanges.
  • Explanation of how existing financial relationships influence Paxos's strategy to avoid direct competition with banks.
  • Recognition of regulatory challenges faced by institutions wanting to adopt blockchain technology.

Crypto Institutions and User Acquisition

  • Crypto institutions like Binance, Kraken, OKX, and Coinbase effectively acquired users globally.
  • Traditional brokers like Charles Schwab were slow to adopt crypto trading options.
  • Regulatory challenges hindered traditional firms from fully engaging in crypto markets.

Regulatory Landscape and Market Evolution

  • Robinhood briefly halted Solana trading due to regulatory oversight but resumed later.
  • Paxos was created to provide trustworthy infrastructure for the evolving financial system.
  • The goal is to offer infrastructure for both crypto firms and traditional institutions.

Infrastructure Providers in Finance

  • Different layers of financial services exist; exchanges are infrastructure providers while banks are not.
  • The Trump administration brought unexpected regulatory clarity for crypto markets.
  • Speculation helped establish crypto as a recognized asset class.

Business Model of Paxos

  • Paxos provides regulated infrastructure for institutions entering the crypto space.
  • Major clients include Revolut, New Bank, PayPal, and others looking to offer crypto services.

Paxos Services Overview

  • Paxos operates wallet services enabling crypto trading and payments through various platforms.
  • The business includes custody solutions and self-custody options after acquiring Fortify.

Tokenization and Global Dollar Network

  • Tokenization is another key aspect of Paxos' business model with a focus on stable coins.
  • The Global Dollar network involves multiple institutions including PayPal, Anchorage, Robinhood, and more.

Business Model and Tokenization

  • The consortium issues tokens with a 50/50 revenue split, including packs gold and tokenized equities.
  • Revenue is generated through asset management fees for stable coins and a combination of SaaS fees and transaction fees on wallets.
  • Wallet usage has minimum requirements; more transactions lead to higher transaction fee earnings.

Comparison with Competitors

  • The speaker believes their product, BUSD, was superior to competitors like Tether and Circle's USDC.
  • BUSD was issued through a regulated entity, unlike Tether, which is unregulated; this created market advantages.
  • Confidence in BUSD stemmed from its growth potential compared to other stablecoins during regulatory challenges.

Regulatory Challenges

  • Regulatory pressures led to the winding down of BUSD due to a Wells notice from the SEC labeling it as a security.
  • The New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) forced the shutdown of their relationship regarding BUSD.
  • There was significant pressure on regulated entities while unregulated players continued operating without similar scrutiny.

Impact on Business Operations

  • The situation surrounding BUSD was seen as unfortunate due to its issuance through a regulated entity.
  • The partnership with Binance was primarily branding-focused rather than compliance or operationally integrated.
  • Regulated entities faced challenges while unregulated ones thrived during industry-wide crackdowns.

Market Cap Insights

  • At its peak, BUSD reached $24 billion in market cap by the end of 2022 after starting at $1 billion in January 2021.
  • Regulatory aspects were highlighted as one of the most challenging experiences for the company during this period.
  • Projected revenues based on market cap indicated significant financial potential that ultimately faced setbacks.

What is the Future of Stable Coins?

Insights on Market Position and Strategy

  • Importance of identifying unique market positions for building stable coins.
  • Challenges faced by USDC due to its economic structure with Coinbase.
  • Potential for global bank consortiums to launch their own dollars.

PayPal's Stable Coin Challenges

  • PayPal's stable coin currently valued at $4 billion, but growth has been slow.
  • SEC subpoena slowed down PayPal’s progress in launching their stable coin.
  • Internal company challenges and CEO turnover have impacted focus on the stable coin.

Legislative Impact on Stable Coins

  • The significance of legislation passed during the Biden administration for the industry.
  • Legal clarity encourages financial institutions to develop stable coin strategies.
  • Laws provide assurance that stable coins are here to stay, influencing institutional decisions.

Competitive Landscape and Regulatory Requirements

  • New regulations require one-to-one reserves and bankruptcy protections for stability.
  • Difficulty in passing legislation reflects market dynamics and stakeholder negotiations.
  • Competitive advantages may shift as regulatory requirements become clearer.

Multi-Jurisdictional Compliance in Token Issuance

  • Discusses the need for multi-jurisdictional compliance to operate a token in Europe and the U.S.
  • Highlights that Circle's Eurocoin lacks primary regulator status in the U.S., unlike their stable coin with two regulators.
  • Emphasizes the complexity of issuing a compliant stable coin, requiring adherence to reserve requirements.

Operational Scale and Market Velocity

  • Notes that over $200 billion of stable coins have been minted and burned, showcasing operational scale.
  • Mentions historical context of dollar stable coin issuance starting around 2018.
  • Explains the structure of the global dollar network allowing members to share economics and governance.

Market Positioning Against Competitors

  • Questions what changes are needed for Paxos issued stable coins to compete with Tether and USDC.
  • States that market share has grown significantly from $1 billion last year to approximately $6 billion now.
  • Identifies four competitive vectors: regulation, rewards distribution, utility, and liquidity.

Building Liquidity and Utility

  • Differentiates between liquidity (ease of trading) and utility (spending options).
  • Acknowledges that building liquidity is more challenging than establishing utility.
  • Describes how market cap impacts growth potential for stable coins like PYD.

Understanding Market Cap and Usage Metrics in Crypto

Market Cap Insights

  • Fake market cap can be a vanity metric; true health is measured by wallet usage and transaction velocity.
  • A $10 billion stable coin may be less effective than a $2 billion one if not actively used.

AI Agents and Their Evolution

  • The evolution of AI agents is still early, but they are beginning to change internet usage patterns.
  • AI can now create strategies for wallets like MetaMask, indicating significant advancements in automation.

Current Sentiment in the Crypto Industry

  • Many long-term crypto builders feel pessimistic despite institutional excitement about crypto's future.
  • The current environment shows a disconnect between regulatory progress and token performance, leading to mixed feelings among investors.

Understanding the Challenges in DeFi

Market Sustainability

  • Discussion on unsustainable DeFi protocols that fail due to lack of network effect and financial resources.
  • Reference to past market downturns, including ICO winters and the collapse of Terra Luna.
  • Emphasis on the freedom in crypto without central bank support, despite potential pain points.

Fundraising Insights

  • Raised $540 million; reflection on whether such a large amount was necessary for business sustainability.
  • Importance of having capital to establish trustworthiness with clients and investors.
  • Other factors influencing trust include regulation, operational history, and security measures.

IPO Considerations

  • No fundraising since 2021; likelihood of going public discussed for next year or beyond.
  • Capital structure's role in business growth; strategic investors can enhance value creation.
  • Going public changes brand perception and access to capital but comes with costs.

Risks of Public Markets

  • Need for consistent revenue growth to meet market expectations when public.
  • Potential downsides of being misunderstood in stock price leading to liquidity issues.
  • Concerns about low stock prices affecting company reputation and investor confidence.

Business Complexity

  • Discussion on complexities within crypto businesses regarding valuation models (SaaS vs. AUM).
  • Mention of Bitco's performance as an example of market volatility impacting perceptions.

Understanding Business Positioning in Crypto

Insights on Market Perception

  • Discussion with a CEO about rebranding as a payments business for higher market multiples.
  • Importance of storytelling and analogies in defining business identity; caution against misleading comparisons.

Market Trends and TAM

  • Bitcoin's price trends resemble software stocks, raising questions about the total addressable market (TAM).
  • Current crypto downturn leads to skepticism about TAM size; contrastingly, the payments sector has enormous potential.

Growth Potential in Payments

  • Payment companies can scale rapidly; examples include Toast and Clover disrupting incumbents.
  • Toast's critical role in restaurant operations highlights the importance of reliable technology solutions.

Strategic Positioning of Paxos

  • Emphasis on redefining Paxos' narrative to align with a larger financial system transformation.
  • The goal is to integrate $900 trillion assets onto blockchain, indicating significant growth opportunities.

Infrastructure Role and Customer Focus

  • Paxos serves as an infrastructure provider rather than acquiring end users directly.
  • Comparison to Visa/Mastercard emphasizes the focus on B2B relationships rather than consumer acquisition.

Business Model Considerations

  • Paxos operates through tokenization and wallet software, creating demand-supply dynamics.
  • Initial positioning aimed at capturing the largest TAM for building a valuable business despite challenges.

Acquisitions and Their Challenges

Understanding Acquisitions

  • 80% of acquisitions fail; caution is essential when considering them.
  • Three types of acquisitions: buying revenues, maintaining independence, or full integration.
  • Successful acquisitions require careful consideration of how they enhance product offerings.

Specific Examples

  • Membrane acquisition involves straightforward license purchases for European operations.
  • Fortify will be integrated into the business to leverage their wallet technology effectively.

Strategic Considerations

  • A good acquisition aligns with customer needs and offers complementary products.
  • Future acquisitions may focus on tokenization and stable coin infrastructure while ensuring proper structuring.

Building a Generational Company

Founders' Advice

  • Prioritization is crucial; determine what to pursue and what to avoid.
  • Horizontal companies face unique challenges in creating growth compared to vertical ones.

Growth Strategies

  • Focus on initiatives that create a flywheel effect for accelerated growth rather than linear progress.
  • Consistency in decision-making is vital; avoid reacting impulsively to trends.

Team Dynamics

  • Keeping team size small reduces coordination costs, enhancing efficiency.

Fundraising Strategies and Business Growth

Understanding Team Dynamics

  • More people in a team can lead to career advancement due to increased responsibilities, but success relies on effective business structures.
  • Hiring great talent is crucial; poor hires can result in low productivity, potentially hindering company growth.

Tips for Fundraising

  • Consider the type of investors and the duration of their capital based on your business goals (20 years vs. 5 years).
  • Match the duration and quality of capital with your business needs to ensure alignment with long-term objectives.

Metrics and Market Fit

  • Focus on essential metrics for fundraising without losing sight of overall business health; chasing metrics alone can be detrimental.
  • Achieving product-market fit requires time and persistence; staying lean during this process is vital for success.
Video description

This week, Charles Cascarilla joins the show to discuss the current state of crypto and the future of Paxos. We deep dive into Paxos’ origin story and business model, the growth of stablecoin payments, whether Paxos may look to IPO in 2027, Charles' advice for founders and more. Enjoy! -- Follow Charles: https://x.com/chadcascarilla Follow Jason: https://x.com/JasonYanowitz Follow Empire: https://x.com/theempirepod -- ZKsync is the Bank Stack of Ethereum. It is a network of chains secured by cryptography, not validators. Its cutting-edge ZK innovation enables the privacy, performance and connectivity that businesses need to thrive in the digital assets economy. To find out more visit: https://www.zksync.io/ -- Timestamps: (00:00) Introduction (02:03) The State of Crypto Today (22:24) How To Fix The U.S Debt Problem (32:24) ZKsync Ad, Blockworks IR (33:56) Behind The Paxos Business Model (43:32) Why Binance’s $BUSD Would Have Been The Largest Stablecoin (50:12) The GENIUS Act & The Global Dollar Network (59:46) Agentic Payments (01:05:32) Will Paxos IPO? (01:17:06) Advice For Founders -- Disclaimer: Nothing said on Empire is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. This podcast is for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our opinions, not financial advice. Santiago, Jason, Rob and our guests may hold positions in the companies, funds, or projects discussed.