Comparing the FiiO FT1 Pro and the Hifiman Edition XS - Which one should you choose?

Headphone Showdown: FT1 Pro vs. Edition XS

Overview of Headphone Releases

• The speaker discusses the frequency of new headphone releases by a brand, noting that most have been well-received except for the FT5, which had mixed reviews due to its dark tuning.

• Introduction of the FT1 Pro, an open-back planar magnetic headphone priced around €200, positioning it against the Edition XS, which has seen a price reduction to €300.

Build Quality Comparison

• Both headphones are noted for their solid build quality; however, the FT1 Pro lacks wood on ear cups but uses durable plastic and metal in critical areas.

• The construction details of the FT1 Pro are highlighted as sturdy with visible planar drivers, while some minor clicking sounds occur during movement but do not significantly detract from overall quality.

• In contrast, the Edition XS is described as feeling less robust and more toy-like compared to the FT1 Pro's sturdier design.

Comfort Assessment

• The comfort level of both models is discussed; the FT1 is praised for being lightweight with good padding but has issues with hot spots on the head due to low clamping force.

• The speaker notes that while both headphones are generally comfortable, they can feel clunky and require adjustment for optimal fit.

• Criticism is directed at the Edition XS's headband design, which lacks adequate cushioning and leads to discomfort over time.

Sound Quality Insights

Audio Review: FT1 Pro vs. Edition XS

Low Frequency Response

• The FT1 Pro exhibits a boost in very low frequencies (40 to 60 Hz), providing surprising force without being overly thick or bass-heavy, maintaining a relatively neutral tuning.

• This low-end response is particularly effective for instruments like bass guitars and kick drums, delivering a visceral listening experience that highlights the capabilities of planar bass.

• While the mid-bass (60 Hz to 250 Hz) remains flat, it does not compromise the body of instruments; however, those seeking a more pronounced bass presence may find the FT1 Pro lacking.

• In comparison, the Edition XS offers thicker bass with greater emphasis from 100 Hz onwards, resulting in a warmer and fuller sound but less tightness than the FT1 Pro.

• The Edition XS's bass can feel more impactful but also less controlled compared to the FT1 Pro's clarity and precision.

Mid-Range Characteristics

• The mid-range of the FT1 Pro is described as flat and slightly forward until reaching a dip between 1,000 Hz and 2,000 Hz, creating a spacious sound without sounding thin or plasticky.

• Instruments and vocals maintain sufficient body with excellent separation; quiet parts are easily discernible due to inherent resolving qualities attributed to planar drivers.

• Electric guitars sound natural on the FT1 Pro without harshness or excessive cleanliness; this contrasts with the Edition XS which has noticeable upper bass emphasis making music sound fuller yet sometimes boomy.

• The Edition XS presents instruments further back in the mix while sounding thinner compared to the FT1 Pro’s more forward presentation of vocals and instruments.

• Overall, while both headphones excel in mid-range performance, listeners may prefer one over another based on their musical preferences regarding fullness versus neutrality.

Treble Performance

• Treble can be divisive among planar headphones; many listeners report an unnatural sheen at higher frequencies. However, the FT1 Pro avoids these issues by maintaining smoothness without sharp peaks that could lead to listener fatigue.

• It features a cohesive treble profile from 5 kHz to 15 kHz that lacks problematic peaks often found in other headphones which can cause certain sounds (like cymbals or vocal sibilance) to become overwhelming.

• This balanced treble allows for aggressive snare drum sounds while keeping cymbals present but not exhausting—ideal for mixing purposes where accurate frequency representation is crucial.

Headphone Comparison: XS vs. FT1 Pro

Sound Profile and Characteristics

• The XS headphone emphasizes bass and treble, providing an airy sound with noticeable high frequencies, contrary to expectations from reviews that suggested a more exhausting listening experience.

• While there is some sharpness in the sound profile, it remains manageable; the clarity contributes to an epic sound experience, differing from the more relaxed tone of the F model.

• The XS features elevated frequencies above 7,000 Hz, enhancing ethereal qualities in female vocals and adding sheen to music without being overly harsh.

Technical Performance

• The FT1 Pro is noted for its detailed soundstage, allowing listeners to easily discern small details in tracks while maintaining a natural quality without compression.

• In direct comparison with the XS, the FT1 Pro appears more controlled and clearer; however, both headphones are highly resolving once users adapt to their tuning.

Staging and Layering

• The FT1 Pro offers a neutral sound that aids in music analysis but lacks the expansive stage of the XS. The XS excels in creating an open atmosphere typical of X-shaped headphones.

• Listening to music through the XS provides a "wow factor," characterized by enjoyment rather than analytical precision; this distinction highlights different user preferences between models.

Conclusion on Headphone Selection

• Both headphones cater to different listener groups: while the FT1 Pro leans towards neutrality suitable for analysis, the XS appeals more broadly due to its engaging sound profile.

• The FT1 Pro's clean bass and thoughtful design make it a strong contender within its price range; however, listeners seeking enjoyment may prefer the wider stage of the Edition XS.

• For casual listeners who might feel overwhelmed by detail-oriented sounds, the Edition XS could be considered superior due to its immersive experience despite being less analytical than its counterpart.